Wed, Nov-30-16, 05:51
|
|
|
|
Plan: P:E/DDF
Stats: 225/150/169
BF:45%/28%/25%
Progress: 134%
Location: NC
|
|
I do not exercise intensely and have no advice except you might try eating more and exercising less
Please read and take to heart Amy Berger's advice on who should not be fasting. Physical stress is not helping your BG, and may be impacting thyroid.
Part 1 is more to the point: http://www.tuitnutrition.com/2016/09/not-so-fast.html
Quote:
Based on what I see, hear, and read in the “Paleosphere,” the people who report the most trouble with fasting—the ones whose “adrenals crashed,” or whose “thyroid got killed”—are women. Usually younger women. Usually younger women who do a great deal of intense exercise. Usually younger women who do a great deal of intense exercise on insufficient calories (from whatever combination of macronutrients you like; doesn’t matter – the bottom line is, it’s just too damn little food). They also usually have full-time jobs and wake up at the crack of dawn to get in a spin class, boot camp, or CrossFit WOD, and sometimes do another one after work. These women are already in metabolic and hormonal danger. Add fasting to that mix and, yes, of course they don’t fare well. Why is this a surprise to anyone?! (*Tap, tap.* Is this thing on?!)
(Case in point: Elle Russ, author of The Paleo Thyroid Solution. According to her profile as a “success story” on Mark’s Daily Apple: “I am 5’2”, I was 110–115 lbs, 16% to 17% body fat, and before hypothyroidism hit me, I exemplified the image of health and fitness. […] My doctor tested my thyroid incorrectly by only testing my TSH. He said the TSH was within range, I did not have a thyroid problem, and I just needed to exercise more and eat less, which I thought was impossible because I had been working out two hours a day and eating 1,200 calories or less…” To be clear, Elle wrote nothing about fasting. I am simply sharing her story as an example of who should not fast, but the kind of person I regularly hear from who is doing so. And I find it inexcusable that none of the doctors she ever saw for her thyroid suggested that she EAT MORE FOOD and EXERCISE A LITTLE LESS. [Also, perhaps 110 pounds and 16% body fat maybe did not “exemplify the image of health and fitness.” And please know I mean absolutely no disrespect toward Ms. Russ. As someone who has struggled with my own thyroid issues, I think her story is an important one, and I’m sure her book will be an incredibly valuable resource for other women, whose doctors are complete morons. I am simply speculating that her thyroid troubles might have—might have—been directly related to working out 2 hours a day on 1200 calories.])
So yes, fasting is great for women. Except for the women it’s not great for. I can almost guarantee you that none of the women claiming that fasting “wrecked their adrenals” or “trashed their thyroid” were 250 pounds, type 2 diabetic, and on five prescription medications. They were probably already following a low carb or Paleo diet, highly active, type-A personalities, severely under-fueling their activity, and already stressed to the max. These people are not suitable candidates for fasting.
|
Last edited by JEY100 : Wed, Nov-30-16 at 06:46.
|