From my site:
http://www.powerhealth.net/articles5.htm
I hope it clarifies some of the myths about fats. I think Dean Ornish needs to read it
The Skinny on Fats & Breast Cancer
by Stephen Byrnes, PhD, RNCP
Originally published in Positive Health (UK), May 2001; WellBeing (Australia), September 2001.
In today’s nutritional world, fat has become a dirty word. Women in particular are encouraged to eat a low-fat diet to help prevent breast cancer, as well as other ailments, including other cancers. Animal fats such as butter have taken a terrible beating in the media over the past few decades and have been blamed for horrific crimes, including obesity, heart disease and cancer. Accordingly, Western peoples have been virtually brainwashed into thinking that butter and other predominantly saturated fats like coconut oil and tallow are unhealthy. So-called safe substitutes like margarine and various vegetable oils have been heavily promoted and advertised with the result being that the public associates these things with health and well-being.
Unfortunately for us, all of these contentions and claims are false. When it comes to breast cancer prevention, and in some cases treatment, the so-called ‘bad fats’ are actually the good guys, and the ‘safe substitutes’ are increasingly being shown up for what they really are: fabricated foods that cause disease, including breast cancer.
ALL FATS ARE NOT THE SAME
A common misconception the general public and some food writers hold is that all fats are essentially the same. This is not true. There are, to be sure, certain fats and oils that we need to avoid, but one must always be very specific as to what those are. Let’s define our terms to end the confusion once and for all. Fatty acids are chains of carbon and hydrogen atoms linked together in certain ways with an acid, or carboxyl group, attached to their end. When three fatty acids are bonded together with a glycerol molecule, the result is a triglyceride. In lipid biochemistry, all fatty acids are classified according to the number of carbon atoms present in their structure, as well as the degree of saturation, or how many hydrogen atoms are bonded to the carbons. A fatty acid that has two hydrogen atoms linked up to each carbon atom is saturated; a fatty acid with two hydrogens missing is monounsaturated; and a fatty acid with four or more hydrogens missing is polyunsaturated. All fats and oils, whether of animal or vegetable origin, are blends of these three types, but with one usually predominating, depending on the food in question.
Saturated fats predominate principally in animal fats, though palm and coconut oils are noted plant sources. Monounsaturated fats abound in nuts, avocadoes, olive oil, and some animal fats (especially lard). Polyunsaturated fats mostly make up vegetable oils, but significant amounts are found in fish oils and chicken skin.
It should be noted here that the more a fat is saturated, the more stable it is chemically. Saturated and monounsaturated fats do not go rancid easily if stored properly. Likewise, these fats are more stable under heat, making them ideal for cooking. Polyunsaturated fats, however, especially those of vegetable origin, are not as stable and go rancid more quickly, even in the body. Rancid oils breed one thing: cancer-causing and tissue-damaging free radicals. While some polyunsaturated fats are needed by the body, the so-called essential fatty acids (EFAs), they should not exceed about 5% of your total caloric intake due to this problem.1,2
The two EFAs are linolenic (an omega-3 fatty acid) and linoleic (an
omega-6 fatty acid). The ‘3’ and ‘6’ indicate where the first double bond occurs in the fatty acid molecule. For example, in an omega-3 fatty acid, the first double bond occurs at the third carbon atom. The body takes the EFAs and creates other omega-3 and 6 fatty acids and hormone-like substances called prostaglandins to carry out a host of metabolic functions.
Like vitamins and minerals, EFAs must be obtained from our food. In times past, humans consumed a balance of linolenic and other omega-3 fatty acids (found principally in cold water fish, walnuts, eggs, flax oil, dark-green leafy vegetables, cod liver oil, and some whole grains) and linoleic and other omega-6 fatty acids (found principally in vegetables), and this is as it should be as both are equally important. When there is an overabundance of linoleic acid in the diet, however, our body’s ability to absorb and utilize linolenic acid is inhibited.1,3 This causes a host of undesirable reactions including sexual and immune dysfunction, and
increased cancer risk.4-6 The Western world has greatly increased its linoleic acid intake due to its higher use of vegetable oils over the past 60 years.7 Not surprisingly, cancer (and heart disease) rates have skyrocketed.
There is another type of ‘fatty acid’ that is produced during chemical processing called a trans-fatty acid (TFA). These are unnatural fats that our bodies cannot utilize properly due to their bizarre chemical structure. In a TFA, a liquid vegetable oil has been made solid by forcing hydrogen atoms into it with the help of a nickel catalyst. In terms of visual appearance, a hydrogenated fat looks like a saturated one, since both are
solid at room temperature. On a molecular level, however, the TFA is quite different, making it unusable by the body. These fake fats are found in margarine, ‘vegetable oil spreads’, vegetable shortening and refined canola oil. It is trans-fatty acid, as opposed to saturated fatty acid, consumption that is strongly correlated with cancer, cardiovascular disease and other diseases.8-12
Talking with a Fat Expert
Dr Mary Enig, PhD, is president of the Maryland Nutritionists
Association, a former research associate of nutritional biochemistry at the University of Maryland, and a recognized international expert in lipid biochemistry. In 1978, Enig and two colleagues published a ground-breaking paper that analysed the claims made for cancer and fat intake.9 Then, as now, the widely accepted notion was that a higher intake of saturated fatty acids increased one’s risk of cancer, while increased consumption of polyunsaturated fatty acids, the kind found in vegetable
oils, offered a protective effect. Enig contended that the actual data showed the exact opposite. In the ensuing years, Enig turned her attention to TFAs, their ever-increasing presence in Western diets, and their roles as disease promoters.13
‘What is wrong with the current dietary advice to prevent breast and other cancers,’ she stated, ‘is that the evidence against ‘fat’ is not defined correctly. There is no solid evidence against the natural fats, whether they are animal or vegetable fats. Research has always shown, however, that the high linoleic acid-containing oils promote experimentally induced cancer, and high lauric acid-containing oils (such as coconut and palm kernel oils) prevent experimentally induced cancer. There is also some published evidence that the TFAs promote breast cancer. As for the claim
that either animal fats or saturated fats promote breast or other cancers, this is not true; there is just the opposite evidence.
‘The TFAs have been shown to correlate with the incidence of breast cancer,’ she continued. ‘There has been at least one research report from the NIH [National Institutes of Health] that showed linoleic acid to be a promoter; this research has not been continued for some reason.
‘Furthermore, research from Europe showed that the TFAs were
higher in tissues of women who had breast cancer. Research from
Denmark and Greece identified the partially hydrogenated vegetable fats and/or margarine with breast cancer.
‘When it comes to other diseases, there is evidence of adverse effects of the TFAs as factors in heart disease, diabetes, poor infant growth and development, and hormonal and immune system dysfunction. TFAs also inhibit prostaglandin synthesis.’14
It would appear, then, that the ‘bad’ fats are the very ones that women have been told to eat more of in the last few decades: margarine, vegetable shortening and vegetable oils (including corn, soy, safflower and cottonseed oils). Furthermore, the evidence implicating TFAs as causative factors in breast cancer is growing stronger. For the woman interested in breast cancer prevention, vegetable oils, margarine and all partially
hydrogenated oils have got to go! Due to their wide presence in processed foods, women should check food labels and be on the lookout for these biochemical marauders.
Are Saturated Fats Bad?
No they are not. Despite current beliefs that saturated fats cause an increased risk of cancer, a long-term study of 60,000 women recently completed in Scandinavia showed no such connection.15 There was, however, a high rate of cancer associated with vegetable oil consumption. This is in keeping with what is being increasingly revealed about vegetable oils: they are bad news.
There are many vital nutrients and substances found in saturated fats. Butter, for example, is rich in several trace minerals, including selenium, a key antioxidant and cancer preventer. Several studies have linked low selenium levels with higher cancer and heart disease rates.16 Butter also contains all the fat-soluble vitamins, especially vitamins A and D, both antioxidants and protective against cancer. Butter also contains fair
amounts of two fatty acids: butyric and lauric. Both of these are antifungal, antibacterial and anticarcinogenic substances.17 (Coconut and palm kernel oils, and Roquefort cheese are significant sources of lauric acid.) Butter is also the best source of a particular fatty acid getting a lot of attention lately:
conjugated linoleic acid (see below).18
Coconut oil is another good example. Formerly used widely in baked goods, this oil is very rich in lauric acid. This fatty acid converts in the intestines into monolaurin, a powerful antifungal, antiviral and antibacterial substance. Coconut oil also contains caprylic acid, also a powerful antifungal. Recent research shows coconut oil to be stimulatory to the immune system and to offer substantial benefits to HIV+ individuals.19-21 Yet these properties are lost amidst a plethora of unwarranted warnings about ‘the dangers of saturated fat’.
Dr Enig added that, ‘The fats that humans have consumed for millennia were almost always more saturated than they were unsaturated. It was the easily extractable fat or oil, such as the fat that came from the animal or, in tropical areas, the oil that came from the coconut or palm fruit, that was used in cooking. People really didn’t have the ability to extract oil from vegetables like corn as they do today. However, people got their EFAs from many of these plants when they were included in the foods the people were eating. This was the way the EFAs were historically consumed.’ In other words, like our ancestors, it’s best to have more saturated fats in your diet and to get your EFAs from whole foods rather than from processed vegetable oils.
Won’t increasing your saturated fat intake increase your chances of heart disease? Dr Enig says, ‘No. The idea that dietary saturated fats and cholesterol cause heart disease or “clogged arteries” is completely wrong. Studies have actually revealed that arterial plaque is mostly made up of unsaturated fats, particularly polyunsaturates.’22
In fact, the body needs saturated fats in order to utilize EFAs properly.23,24 Saturated fats also lower the blood levels of the artery-damaging lipoprotein A (LpA levels are elevated by TFAs);25-28 are needed for proper calcium utilization in the bones;29,30 stimulate the immune system;31,32 are the preferred food for the heart and other vital organs;33,34 and, along with cholesterol, add structural stability to the cell wall.2 Dr Enig further comments that, ‘Increasing one’s intake of saturates spares the body’s supply of antioxidants which get rapidly used up with a high polyunsaturated fat diet. This is another way that saturates protect against cancer.’
One caveat: it’s important to try to obtain organic sources of your fats as environmental toxins are lipophilic, or ‘fat loving’. It’s worth a few more pennies to look for organic butter, milk, cheese and other animal foods. If your budget just won’t permit you to buy organic all of the time, then purchase organic sources of the food items that you use the most to minimize your exposure to possible toxins.
Conjugated Linoleic Acid
Conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) is a fatty acid produced by ruminating animals such as cows. Dr Enig states that, ‘CLA is an isomer of linoleic acid; the natural forms are found in milk fat (especially high-fat cheeses) and meat fat. CLA has been shown to inhibit the development of cancer, including breast cancer’. Indeed, the October 2000 issue of the Journal of the American College of Nutrition contained a research abstract describing how CLA inhibited breast cancer cell growth.35,36 As a side
benefit, several studies have shown CLA to promote muscle growth and fat burning by the body.37,38 In other words, CLA is a fatty acid that helps you lose unwanted fat and build a leaner body.
Where do you find CLA? Some supplement companies now manufacture CLA in capsule form, but the best source is fat from grass-fed cows. It’s important that you look for full-fat dairy products (milk, cheese, butter) and meats from grass-fed animals. Why? Because cows manufacture CLA from grass in their stomachs.39,40 Commercially-raised cows that only eat soybeans or corn meal produce little, if any, CLA. New Zealand’s butter and meat products are from grass-fed livestock, as are those from smaller farms (see end of this article for sources). It should be pointed out here that non- or low-fat dairy foods will obviously contain little or no CLA (or the fat-soluble vitamins A and D). Consuming skim or low-fat milk, cheese and yoghurt will automatically deprive the health-minded woman of several important nutrients.
How sad that modern farming methods, with their de-emphasis on grass feeding, deprive us of such a healthful fat! It is also unfortunate that establishment nutritionists have urged women and the public away from full-fat dairy products and butter: the best sources of CLA.
The Right Fat Diet
Avoiding phoney fats like margarine and vegetable shortening, as well as processed vegetable oils that are high in polyunsaturates, is a must for any woman looking to prevent breast cancer and ill health. Taking extra care to include organic sources of healthy fats like olive oil, butter and
coconut oil, as well as CLA-rich foods from grass-fed cattle, will help prevent breast cancer and other diseases. Dr Enig agrees, ‘The best dietary advice is to avoid partially hydrogenated vegetable oils and high levels of omega-6 oils. Use a broad balance of natural fats and oils and consume as many whole foods and whole food mixtures as possible.’
Stephen Byrnes' new book, Diet and Heart Disease: Its NOT What You Think (Whitman Books; 2001) is available from amazon.com or your local book store. Visit his website to receive his free ezine:
www.PowerHealth.net
SOURCES
Mary Enig's book Know Your Fats is available from amazon.com or from
www.Bethesda Press.com. Dr, Enig can be contacted at Enig Associates, Inc., (301) 680-8600. Papers by Dr. Enig on coconut oil and other fats can be found at
www.WestonAPrice.org.
For sources of organic, grass-fed butter and other animal foods, check your local health food market, or the Weston A. Price Foundation which maintains a list of nationwide farms and cooperatives. See above for web address or call (202) 333-HEAL.
REFERENCES
1. Lasserre M et al. Lipids. 20(4): 227. 1985
2. Fallon S and Enig M. Nourishing Traditions. 2nd ed. New Trends
Publishing. Washington DC. pp10-11. 1999.
3. Kinsella JE. Food Technology. p134. October 1988.
4. Horrobin DF. Reviews in Pure and Pharmacological Sciences. Freund
Publishing House. 4: 339-383. 1983.
5. Devlin TM ed. Textbook of Biochemistry. 2nd ed. Wiley Medical.
pp429-430. 1982.
6. Fallon S and Enig MG. Tripping Lightly Down the Prostaglandin Pathways.
Jnl of Price-Pottenger Nutr Fnd. 20(3): 5-8. 1996. Posted at
www.WestonAprice.org
7. Rizek RL et al. Fat in Today’s Food Supply. Jnl Amer Oil Chem Soc. 51:
244. 1974.
8. Mann G. Metabolic Consequences of Dietary Trans-fatty Acids. Lancet.
343: 1268-71. 1994.
9. Enig MG et al. Fed Proc. 37: 2215. July 1978.
10. Kummerow F. Nutritional Effects of Isomeric Fats. in Horisberger and
Bracco eds. Dietary Fats and Health. Amer Oil Chem Soc. Illinois.
pp391-402. 1983.
11. Schantz EJ et al. Jnl Dairy Sci. 23: 181-89. 1940.
12. Watkins BA et al. Br Poul Sci. 32(5): 1109-19. December 1991.
13. Enig MG. Trans Fatty Acids in the Food Supply: A Comprehensive Report
Covering 60 Years of Research. 2nd ed. Enig Associates Inc. Maryland.
1995.
14. Enig MG. Personal interview. 4 January 2001.
15. Wolk A et al. Arch of Inter Med. 158: 41. 1998.
16. Studies summarized by Lieberman S and Bruning N. The Real Vitamin
and Mineral Book. 2nd ed. Avery Publishing Group. New York. pp299-302.
1997.
17. Shanks L et al. in Kabara J ed. Symposium on the Pharmacological
Effects of Lipids. American Oil Chemists Society. Illinois. pp51-62. 1978.
18. Fallon S and Enig MG. Why Butter is Better. Posted at
http://www.WestonAPrice.org. Accessed on 4 January 2001.
19. Enig MG. Lauric Oils as Antimicrobial Agents: Theory of Effect, Scientific
Rationale, and Dietary Application as Adjunct Nutritional Support for
HIV-Infected Individuals. in Watson R ed. Food and Nutrients in AIDS. CRC
Press. Florida, pp81-97. 1999.
20. Isaacs CE, Kim KS and Thormar H. Inactivation of Enveloped Viruses in
Human Bodily Fluids by Purified Lipids. Annal NY Acad Sci. 724: 457. 1994.
21. Sadeghi S et al. Dietary Lipids Modify the Cytokine Response to
Bacterial Lipopolysaccharide in Mice. Immunology. 96(3): 404-10. 1999.
22. Felton CV et al. Dietary Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids and Composition of
Human Aortic Plaques. Lancet. 344: 1195. 1994.
23. Garg ML et al. FASEB Jnl. 2(4): A852. 1988.
24. Oliart Ros RM et al. Meeting Abstracts. AOCS Proceedings. Chicago.
p7. May 1998.
25. Dahlen GH et al. J Intern Med. 244(5): 417-24. Nov 1998.
26. Khosla P and Hayes KC. J Am Coll Nutr. 15: 325-339. 1996.
27. Clevidence BA et al. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 17: 1657-61. 1997.
28. Enig MG. Fat Facts: Trans Fats and Saturated Fats are Not the Same.
Jnl of Price-Pottenger Nutr Fnd. Winter 1998.
29. Watkins BA et al. Importance of Vitamin E in Bone Formation and in
Chondrocyte Function. ACOS Proceedings. Purdue University. Lafayette.
Indiana. 1996.
30. Watkins BA and Seifert MF. Food Lipids and Bone Health. in McDonald
RE and Min DB eds. Food Lipids and Health. Marcel Dekker Inc. New York.
p101. 1996.
31. Kabara JJ. The Pharmacological Effects of Lipids. The American Oil
Chemists Society. Champaign. Illinois. pp1-14. 1978.
32. Cohen LA et al. Meeting Abstracts. FASEB Jnl. 204(1): A222. Mar 1999.
33. Lawson LD and Kummerow F. Lipids. 14: 501-503. 1979.
34. Garg ML. Lipids. 24(4): 334-9. 1989.
35. See also Ip C, Banni S, Angioni E, Carta G, McGinley J, Thompson HJ,
Barbano D and Baumann D. Conjugated Linoleic Acid-Enriched Butter Fat
Alters Mammary Gland Morphogenesis and Reduces Cancer Risk in Rats.
Jnl of Nutr. 129: 2135-2142.
36. Hubbard NE, Lim D, Summers L and Erickson KL. Reduction of Murine
Mammary Tumor Metastasis by Conjugated Linoleic Acid. Cancer Lett.
150(1): 93-100.13 Mar 2000.
37. Gavino VC, Gavino G, Leblanc MJ and Tuchweber B. An Isomeric Mixture
of Conjugated Linoleic Acids but not Pur Cis-9, Trans-11-Octadecadienoic
Acid Affects Body Weight Gain and Plasma Lipids in Hamsters. Jnl of Nutr.
130(1): 27-9. January 2000.
38. Ostrowska E, Muralithraran M, Cross RF, Bauman DE and Dunshea FR.
Dietary Conjugated Linoleic Acids Increase Lean Tissue and Decrease Fat
Deposition in Growing Pigs. Jnl of Nutr. 129(11): 2037-42. November 1999.
39. Belury MA. Nutr Rev. 53(4): 83-89. April 1995.
40. Kelly ML et al. Jnl Dairy Sci. 81(6): 1630-6. June 1998.
The Skinny on Fats & Breast Cancer
Linear Mode
