Quote:
Originally Posted by amandawald
Yeah, that's absolutely true: all restrictive diets will slow down your thyroid and Atkins admits this quite openly in DANDR.
|
Our ancestors ate just meat, fat, and very few carbs for hundreds of thousands of years. Is this considered a "restrictive diet"? Do you think they all developed thyroid problems? That doesn't make sense, evolutionarily speaking. And why would it be considered restrictive? Just because it doesn't contain a bunch of vegetables and fruit that weren't even available then as they are today?
Even though biologically speaking we are all the same species and should reap the same benefits from our "natural" diet (which to my mind is meat, fat, and very little carbohydrate), people do seem to react to different foods in different ways. Anyone who knows me knows that I'm struggling terribly lately. Whether I consistently eat 2000 calories or 1500 calories or 800 calories, I will lose weight for the first week or two, and then gain it all back in the next week or two without changing anything I'm doing. Some people are insisting to me that I absolutely need to eat a lot more veggies. And yet there's OregonRose and many others who could only lose weight and reach their goal by
eliminating all veggies. There seems to be no one right way to lose pounds.
The longer I do this, the more I realize that it doesn't matter what worked for this person or that person, it only matters what works for you. And determining what works for you is a long, slow, drawn-out process. Some people likely will never find the answer. I just hope I'm not one of them.
Regarding the gastric bypass and weight-loss surgery, I personally know three people who have have this done in the past 10 years. Two flew the surgery and resulting weight loss with no problems, and one had a lot of problems (including several corrective surgeries) but she had major health issues prior to the surgery. Still, all three of them got to a good healthy weight and are thriving. None has gained back the weight, or even a portion of it.
There are horror stories to be found with virtually all surgeries.