Seems my response to this thread was misunderstood. I specifically mentioned that some people do well at 40 or more carbs including my own husband who never did induction.

Atkins 40 is not a book. It is a new push on the Atkins sales website to sell more products and is promoting that most carbs are not coming from veggies but other products including bars, shakes, frozen meals, and ice cream.

Again, whatever works for each individual. I just feel bad for new people that think they are starting a new woe and believe they are following Dr. Atkins plan then wonder why it isn't working for them when they don't drop weight while having indulge bars, bread items, and Edy's ice cream.

I will move on because as I also pointed out - there are other parts of this forum suited for arguing. Best wishes to all.