Cotonpal, she isn't my dietician, just one bashing anyone trying to use a dietary approach to lose weight. I haven't figured out what exactly she presumes to do about being overweight and clearly having health issues do to that very thing. I suppose she'd say for me to actually hire her which I couldn't afford anyway. The anti-diet bandwagon is a scam I think to make a profit off of people who've tried everything and haven't been able to succeed. Either way, I'm trying to cross reference her claims just to see how wrong she actually is.