Maybe that was always my problem on PP/Atkins, I wanted to eat high protein AND high fat.

I'm actually experimenting with higher protein (100g a day instead of my protein minimum of 70g per the old PP method) and the least *added* fat I can get away with, and about 30g a day of "full carbs." Any fat *inside* the food, I don't worry about. Too soon to say whether or not it's helping me lose this vacation weight...but I feel pretty satisfied so far.