Cholesterol Levels: Heart of the Matter, Dietary Villains
A half-hour major television network serious science show debunking the lipid hypothesis in Australia: Heart of the Matter, Dietary Villains
Quote:
http://vimeo.com/77730824 From Dr. Eades blog: Quote:
http://www.proteinpower.com/drmike/...ypothesis/5257/ Dr. Eades, Sinatra, Bowden and Gary Taubes featured. |
About ten minutes into the video, a fellow from the National Heart Foundation in Australia makes the argument that dietary interventions are hard--that saturated fat clearly causes heart disease by raising cholesterol, but that it's almost impossible to prove this in a study because of poor long-term compliance. This is the second thread in several days in which an "expert" made this defense. How damning is that? If the best defense that the diet-heart hypothesis (saturated fat is the villain) defenders can come up with is that their position is true but unproven (and pretty much unprovable)--well, you wouldn't choose that as your defense if you had a better alternative, would you?
Even if he was right--what does he have? An intervention that it's impossible to get the general public to actually adhere to. Certainty that people can flap their butt cheeks and fly to the moon is pretty useless if you can't actually get anybody to try it. |
Cholesterol levels: Are they really that important?
More from Dr. Mike
The Blog of Michael R. Eades, M.D. Cholesterol levels: Are they really that important? Posted: 24 Oct 2013 02:01 PM PDT Is cholesterol the villain it is made out to be by the medical authorities? Does too much cholesterol cause heart disease? Will it shorten your life? Should you avoid saturated fats to stay free from heart disease? The answers to these questions are not the ones most people would anticipate. The video below provides a different perspective. About three months ago I got an email from a television producer in Australia informing me she was going to be in the US and would like to interview me. I consented, and the resultant TV show was just show last night in Oz. It may be the first time a major television network devoted a serious show to debunking the lipid hypothesis. As readers of the blog are all too aware, most take the opposite approach. Let’s hope this one starts a trend. It would be nice to have an investigative reporter go after a lot of these mainstream lipid guys. As you will see, they look pretty uncomfortable under intensive questioning. Unlike those of us on this side of the debate, they’re not used to being questioned as to the validity of their views. Enjoy! Click here to view the embedded video. The post Cholesterol levels: Are they really that important? appeared first on The Blog of Michael R. Eades, M.D.. |
:lol: He has the deer in the headlights look after some of her questions. Their Facebook page goes into classic crisis mode...Fat? Did we say fat? Let's talk about Salt. http://www.dietdoctor.com/heart-fou...is-mode-tv-show
Quote:
|
The Facebook comments are great!
|
The official "Everything in Moderation" response has had multiple requests to see that evidence base...we're still waiting...
Quote:
|
Quote:
Glad to know heroin's okay then :) The human habit of defensiveness seems to serve no useful purpose except as a way of saving one's hide in a punitive society. I find it's great to admit when I'm wrong; I dodge a lot of suffering that way. Look at Ancel Keyes; I do believe he hung in there as long as he did to squish any opposition to the stuff which made him famous. Can you sue scientists for being bad scientists? Can we sue doctors who didn't know any better? To me, the resistance to shifting with new evidence is what should get people all upset. As we say in the US; it's always the cover-up that gets you. |
Australian Heart Foundation Response
The Aust. HF is getting well-deserved criticism for the requirements for its 'tick of approval'. Tick criteria
Quote:
In my neck of the woods ticks are very unhealthy. They carry Lyme disease ;-). |
Quote:
I like this response in the Aust. HF Facebook comments: Quote:
|
Speaking of moderation, there's a new study out suggesting that ApoE4 carriers shouldn't drink moderately or even lightly.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24049153 |
....... and in answer to the obesity epidemic in the UK........http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-24668937
Jo xxx |
But do keep in mind that most people can eat far higher amounts of carbs and even wheat than others of us. And even the much maligned food pyramid suggested about 200 grams of carbs plus fruit. Far less than many of us were eating in the 60s, 70s, and 80s.
|
I don't know about most people, long-term, in this culture. I don't have a lot of friends who haven't ended up pot-bellied in middle age. When I was eighteen, I probably looked like somebody who could afford to eat lots of carbs--even as early as twenty-five, and I most decidedly did not.
|
I really enjoyed the raw footage of the video interviews for this piece. I specially enjoyed Gary Taubes interview. Many people have trouble understanding how the authorities could have gotten it so horribly wrong and are doubtful for that reason. "Saturated fat is bad", and "cholesterol causes heart disease" have been proven beyond the shadow of doubt by now no ? Gary's paints a horrible, but very compelling picture of how it all went so wrong. Basically the health authorities have been trying to prove to the public that coins have only one side. It's easy to do if you discard all evidence that coins have a flip side.
I love short videos like that, because they are more compelling than dry text. The next time someone expresses astonishment that the prevailing theories could be wrong, you can point them to this video. |
.... and then theres this!!!!!!!!!! http://www.abc.net.au/pm/content/2013/s3878646.htm
As my hero, Dr. Malcolm Kendric says "If you cannot win the argument, bully your opponents into submission" Jo xxx |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 18:52. |
Copyright © 2000-2024 Active Low-Carber Forums @ forum.lowcarber.org
Powered by: vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.