Mack,
I think that we have to distinguish between the noncompliance
that comes from denial--a real and prevalent problem, and the
noncompliance that results when patients try the diets and
meds their doctors prescribe only to find that they have no
effect on their control
All too often, the female patient who goes on a low fat low
cal diet and can't lose weight is often accused of being
"noncompliant" and told that she's lying about her diet, or
not counting calories correctly. I have had this happen.
When her blood sugar goes up on the 300 grams a day of
carbs the Nutritionist prescribes, it is very easy to
decide that diet is ineffective, degeneration the only
future, so what the hell.
The stats from articles writing about how great Avandia is for
control are interesting. The typical patient has a fasting
blood sugar near 200 mg/dl and with Avandia it drops 30 mg/dl.
This is hailed as a great response. But the patient is still
way too high and feels like crap all the time. Their
complications aren't getting better either.
Finally, a lot of newly diagnosed patients are hearing from
their doctors that type 2s will deteriorate no matter what
they do. A lot decide that if that's the case, why starve and
torment themselves with drugs that have nasty side effects. If
the diet and meds prescribed make you feel like crap and don't
do anything to control your blood sugar, yes, you will end up
noncompliant.
Give the patient a diet that works to control blood sugars and
meds including insulin that bring down the blood sugars
effectively, and you might see a whole different pattern with
compliance.
-- Jenny - Low Carbing for 4 years. At goal for weight.
Type 2 diabetes, hba1c 5.2. Cut the carbs to respond to my
email address!
Low carb facts and figures, my weight-loss photos, tips,
recipes, strategies for dealing with diabetes and more at
http://www.geocities.com/jenny_the_bean/
Looking for help controlling your blood sugar? Visit
http://www.alt-support-diabetes.org/Newly%20Diagnosed.htm
"Mack©®" <asdnospamhere~example.com> wrote in message
news

mds50hos5rmoj0p154rpa8lh4438erli7~4ax.com...
> On Sun, 21 Mar 2004 21:46:12 GMT, JonK
> <jon~the-kaplansNOSPAM.com> wrote:
>
> >In a separate thread, people are marveling at the fact that
> >the average A1c in America is 9%. The logical conclusion
> >most are coming to is that it must be bad medical advice.
> >
> >In defense of the doctors, I think people have to look at
> >denial and non-compliance.
>
> non-compliance has become the catch word for diabetes. There
> are some who are in denial, some who are non-compliant and
> just as many who have doctors who settle for less than
> optimal numbers because they either don't want to put forth
> the effort to motivate the individual or simply believe it
> is not got to make any difference. You also have to keep in
> mind that the majority of diabetics are NOT under the care
> of specialists.
>
> Mack©® Type 1 since 1975 http://www.alt-support-diabetes.org
> http://www.insulin-pumpers.org
>
> In tribute to the United States of America and the State of
> Israel, two bastions of strength in a world filled with
> strife and terrorism.
>
> "To announce that there must be no criticism of the
> President, or that we are to stand by the President
> right or wrong, is not only unpatriotic and servile,
> but is morally treasonable to the American public."
>
> ...Theodore Roosevelt
> >
> >I go to Kaiser in LA (Sunset, if you know the area) which
> >services a large central city population. My nurse-DCE has
> >told me that most of her patients won't even test once a
> >day. She rarely recommends MDI because most of her patients
> >won't do it. She figures she's lucky if they will take one
> >or two shots a day.
> >
> >My sister just took the class in intro to diabetes. They of
> >course taught the food pyramid. After the class she asked
> >the instructor why she didn't differentiate between fast
> >and slow carbos - like whole wheat bread over white bread.
> >The response was that they try to limit their
> >recommendations to what people actually might do.
> >
> >So all the advice offered is aimed at the lowest common
> >denominator.
> >
> >A friend of my daughter's lives in South Central LA. His
> >mother is severely obese and diabetic. She takes Glucophage
> >and tests once a day in the morning when she remembers. She
> >runs in the 150s and figures that means she's doing good.
> >Coke remains her drink of choice since Diet Coke tastes
> >awful to her. And she's an excellent cook who does a lot of
> >baking. Her brother just had a leg removed. That event has
> >had no impact in her diabetic regimen, nor his.
> >
> >These are not stupid people, just very poor. She works
> >(rather worked, when she could still walk) as a pharmacy
> >tech. She knows about diabetes and all the drugs involved.
> >She's just in severe denial. So are her children who are
> >both obese and one of whom is a diagnosed diabetic.
> >
> >Everybody in this news group is part of an elite: they can
> >read, write and get on the internet - and find news groups.
> >By definition, the performance level in this group is going
> >to far exceed the national average.
> >
> >Additionally, the encouragement and sense of community in
> >this group pushes people to a higher level of performance
> >than they would achieve with the same level of knowledge
> >but without the group.
> >
> >So I'm not surprised that the average A1c is as high as 9%;
> >I'm surprised it's that low.
> >
> >Jon