Hi Delta,
Glad to have a response to my comments but I have a couple of issues with what you have said.
"Try to get the majority from unsaturated sources (fish oil is King) IMO"
What is wrong with saturated fat? In my opinion and in many others it is one of the best types of fat available. Please don't tell me you still believe all the crap about saturated fat being bad for you?
"What has worked for me and many I have shared discussions with, is to keep the protein high (1-1.5g per lb LBM)"
In my opinion this is to high a level of protein. I way approx 160 lb at 8% body fat. This give me a LBM of appox 142 Lbs... I would say 140 grams of protein would be more than adequate - so 1 per lb of LBM is about right. However upping it to 220 grams per day would probably cause me to start burning glucose again and take me partially out of ketosis etc.
"What has worked for me and many I have shared discussions with, is to keep the protein high (1-1.5g per lb LBM), carbs lowish and fat moderate"
IMO carbs should be low, protien moderate, and fat high. Doing it any other way seems to be missing the point (IE people still havn't rid themselves of the notion that fat is bad). People who continue to avoid fat when on a low carb diet are asking for problems.
This may prove interesting reading for you guys:
http://www.second-opinions.co.uk/fat-not-protein.html
"Calories DO matter and in order to lose fat you want to starve it while feeding the lean muscle tissue. FWIW a caloric deficit and feeding the metabolically active muscle is what it all comes down to."
Again, although I think Energy in vs Energy does have some merits, it also has several limitations... Check this out:
http://www.second-opinions.co.uk/do...ally-count.html
Another site I have read quite a bit on quotes these ratios as being ideal, and I have to say they worked wonders for me:
70% total fat on a calorie basis
27% protein
3% carbohydrates (20 gm of which 3 gm or less is fiber).
The site I have mentioned is run by a guy called Barry Groves who has authored a book on low carbing. He is very knowledgable and will respond to Emails.
Let me know your thoughts Delta - it's interesting to get a debate going.
Cheers.