
Mon, Apr-09-07, 12:49
|
|
Senior Member
Posts: 4,629
|
|
Plan: Generic LC with tweaks
Stats: 204/178/165
BF:
Progress: 67%
Location: NC
|
|
With all due respect,
Without knowing exactly what was wrapped around what the doctor said, it's hard to say if the intent was idiotic or not.
1. Once it was clear the presenting patient was not at cardiac risk, unfortunately, she became a hindrance. Presumably, the ER was full of other people also in need of some kind of care and at that moment, more at risk of dying. A UTI is rarely a life-and-death emergency, compared to whatever else may be happening in ER at the time.
2. A LC diet will not, in itself, cause a UTI. However, a change in diet (however explained or mis-understood by someone taking notes) can change body chemistry, and that can be what makes someone susceptible to a UTI.
3. We're all awash in the requisite bacteria all the time. How come we're not all down with UTIs then, and how often is it that we get them "at the worst possible time," ie when something else has changed the way our bodies are able to respond?
4. Plenty enough of us know about "honeymoon cystitis," when a sudden change for the better in general sexual activity can lead to a UTI. I can make this story work in my mind, given the starting conditions. It's not exactly diet-related, but it's not not diet related, either, if you're following.
|