PDA

View Full Version : Schools ban cheese on jacket potatoes in drive to tackle obesity


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



Demi
Tue, Jul-22-08, 09:14
The Mail
London, UK
22 July, 2008


Schools ban cheese on jacket potatoes in drive to tackle obesity

Crisps, sweets and chips are all treats associated with an unhealthy diet.

But a jacket potato with cheese would appear to be a nutritious choice for a growing child.

Apparently not according to Plymouth City Council who have banned the seemingly innocuous meal from school dinner menus.

Do-gooding council chiefs say that over-indulging on cheese could cause youngsters to consume too much saturated fat.

The move comes as part of the authority's drive to hit Government standards set by the School Food Trust aimed at tackling childhood obesity.

A city council spokeswoman said: 'To meet these standards, some food items and ingredients have had to be changed or their use limited.

'Cheese is no longer used as a filling for jacket potatoes, but this has enabled us to keep it as an ingredient on other popular menu choices including pizza, cauliflower cheese, quiche, broccoli bake, pork balls and lentil loaf.'

It also includes replacing salt with herbs and spices, limiting saturated fats and increasing levels of zinc and iron.

However the British Cheese Board said cheese should not be sacrificed from school meals because it is rich in key nutrients, calcium and vitamin A.

Nigel White, secretary of the British Cheese Board, said: 'The council may be sending out the wrong message here.

'Cheese is not part of the problem, it should be part of the solution to children getting a balanced diet.'

Mr White said a debate had raged with the School Food Trust, the Food Standards Agency and the Department of Health who see reducing cheese consumption as a way of tackling the ever-increasing waistlines of today's pupils.

But Mr White stressed cheese is different to junk foods such as crisps and soft drinks, which have lots of calories but not many nutrients.

He stressed that for a child aged seven to ten, 30g of cheese provided 40 per cent of the daily calcium requirement, 72 per cent of vitamin B12, 34 per cent of phosphorus, 28 per cent of protein and 28 per cent of vitamin A.

Dentists also recommend eating cheese to build strong teeth.

Mr White said cheese eaten in moderation was good for people and local authorities should try to obtain half-fat and reduced fat cheeses.

And he stressed: 'There are other things they should be doing, like encouraging children to take more exercise and be careful about how many junk foods they eat.'

Dr Clare Pettinger, a dietician from the University of Plymouth, said cheese was an important part of a child's diet, but warned it was easy to eat too much.

'People will readily put cheese on everything,' she said.

'It's all about variety and balance. Have cheese for one meal and then not for a couple of days.'


http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1037196/Primary-schools-banned-putting-cheese-jacket-potatoes-drive-tackle-obesity.html

MandalayVA
Tue, Jul-22-08, 09:17
Screw the potato, give me the cheese! :D

pennink
Tue, Jul-22-08, 09:17
the world is upside down.

I bet EVERYONE of their great grammas knew to dump starches and sugars when you wanted to lose weight.

what a shame.

mike_d
Tue, Jul-22-08, 10:59
How about just serving the jacket, that contains most of the nutrition in the potato, with a dollop of Daisy, diced bacon and shredded cheddar?

KarenJ
Tue, Jul-22-08, 11:16
How about just serving the jacket, that contains most of the nutrition in the potato, with a dollop of Daisy, diced bacon and shredded cheddar?

Is "jacket potatoes" what we would call potato skins? If so, I like mike_d's idea.

It's good that Nigel White, secretary of the British Cheese Board is fighting back.
:thup:

ReginaW
Tue, Jul-22-08, 11:19
Unfortunately the various school lunch programs rarely look at the impact small changes make on nutrient profiles.

Remove the cheese and you've cut calories, but as mentioned in the article, also reduced calcium, B12, phosphorus, vitamin A and protein.

How do you replace those nutrients? Or do you just ignore them because the calories are lower now?

gwynne2
Tue, Jul-22-08, 11:52
Is "jacket potatoes" what we would call potato skins? If so, I like mike_d's idea.

I think it's a baked potato. Crazy Brits!

;)

Dodger
Tue, Jul-22-08, 11:53
Yep, removing cheese calories reduces micro-nutrients. The potato doesn't have many, so something else with lots of micro-nutrients has to be added.

ruthla
Tue, Jul-22-08, 12:20
I'm suprized they're saying to remove the cheese completely, rather than subsitute inferior lowfat cheese for the full fat variety.

Wifezilla
Tue, Jul-22-08, 12:29
This isn't about cheese. It is about money. Cheese is expensive. They will save a lot of money by not serving cheese. Just like those "wankers" who want to eliminate full-fat milk from schools in England. They are sacrificing kid's health to save a few bucks.

ethang
Tue, Jul-22-08, 13:01
I remember back when I was in high school. The options in the cafeteria were all awful. Poutine (fried potatos with curds and gravy), pizza, burgers, cookies....

I applaud their effort to fight obesity - though somewhat misguided...

I guess our WOE is still not globally viewed as the healthiest. Too bad.

M Levac
Thu, Jul-24-08, 15:46
A priori, the brain can't function properly when it's malnourished.

A potato is starch. It's converted to glucose easily. When it's combined with fat, such as cheese, it's converted less easily or at least less quickly. This means it affects blood glucose less abruptly over a longer period. The same thing happens with ice cream. Removing the cheese and thus the fat will allow the potato to affect blood glucose more quickly and more dramatically. In other words, the meal becomes more toxic. It also becomes less nutritious since fat is nutritious.

Maybe if they'd eaten more fat, they'd have realized how stupid they were in making that decision. Catch 22.

Wifezilla
Thu, Jul-24-08, 16:36
Maybe if they'd eaten more fat, they'd have realized how stupid they were in making that decision. Catch 22.

I was just thinking that...LOL