PDA

View Full Version : Confessions From A Personal Trainer


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



PilotGal
Sun, Feb-24-08, 08:07
this is a very good read.

As your personal fitness trainer my passion is to teach, coach, understand, push, prod, cajole, investigate, research and apply, over and over… As a ‘Fitness Role Model’…well…I feel vulnerable with weakness, so, in hopes we can all learn, from my own weakness, here goes…My Confession.
Last year I had a number of clients who started stubbornly on the Atkins diet despite my warnings. Immediately I saw almost profound results in their weight loss. I reminded them it was the loss of water weight, and warned of the strain on the kidneys and the high cholesterol risk.

During this time I was mastering my yoga practice as a complete vegan but found that my immune system had been profoundly compromised and I was currently on my third cold for the fall season
Atkins was in the media again because of new study results indicating lowered cholesterol. I went to the Atkins book yet again with a more open mind, and decided to try the diet. I liked the contrarian view point to the current AMA position of the low fat diet, which seemed to be producing a society of increasing obesity. Atkins view of sugar as the culprit making you fat, not fat, made sense and the extra work from all the protein for the kidneys… it’s benign. I wanted to use his diet as a tool to get myself entirely off of any sugar.

I started out on the high protein, low carb aspect of the diet. As I reintroduced the animal proteins into my diet I could feel myself get stronger and the colds, finally stopped. I also saw my muscle bellies start to open and swell again. The cold of winter was not as painful as it had been while on my vegan diet.

I then summoned up the courage to start bringing fats into my diet, including bacon, egg yolks, cream cheese, heavy cream, whipped cream, even bacon rinds. On a daily basis I would marvel at having eaten these “forbidden foods” only to awaken the next day thin, svelte. I couldn’t believe this, result! I was loving eating all these foods so familiar yet banished since …childhood

I felt strong, but I had no energy!!! My walks on the beach were lethargic, I had to force myself to go that extra mile. I was thin but I felt like a beached whale. My love affair with Atkins continued a few more months. I followed his prescriptions religiously.
Eventually I had to add more carbs, I needed more energy. By carbs I mean vegetables, salads and whole grains. At this point I gained back the total of two pounds I had lost on Atkins. Body fat went from 16% to 18%, my energy was better. After 7 months I decided it was time to get the blood checked out and to my horror discovered that my cholesterol which had always been around 150 had rocketed up to 300!! Luckily my HDL to LDL ratio was still at a healthy level. Thanks to my forcing myself to exercise, I kept my HDLs high.

I immediately started drinking hot lemon juice with cayenne pepper every morning to clean my blood. I have now thrown away all the high fat foods and have once again, come back full circle to moderation and balance. A balanced diet. It takes a little more discipline but my energy is back and I can now eat the same meals as my husband so dinner preparation is simpler. My weight has not changed since I gradually introduced the carbs. I avoid at all costs the “white foods” flour, sugar, milk. I drink unsweetened soy milk I avoid foods in packages, boxes and bags. I feel a fine layer of fat but that’s okay its winter, I need it, and in the summer, heat always melts it off. I am completely off sugar and alcohol to keep blood sugar low.

her story (http://www.healthfitnessworld.com/articles/fitness/confessions-of-a-personal-fitness-trainer.html)

M Levac
Sun, Feb-24-08, 08:56
I don't know how old she is but with 22 years of experience as her bio says, I think she's old enough to have developed a high insulin resistance. High insulin resistance translates into low glucose burning efficiency. She requires more glucose to stimulate more insulin to finally feed her cells with glucose. Cut out the carbs and she doesn't have enough glucose to feed herself. So she doesn't have energy.

She puts the high fat food back into her diet but still doesn't have enough energy. This is because of the high insulin resistance and the high insulin level. She can't initiate lipolysis properly so she can't use fatty acids as fuel. At least not enough to feel energized like most of us are especially after the first couple of weeks of induction.

Or she forgot to count some carbs somewhere that she can't give up and thinks it can't make that much of a difference. So she's still eating carbs, still has high glucose level, still has high insulin level, still can't go into lipolysis, still has no energy. She thinks that adding back some carbs will do the trick. It does but only because then it increases glucose level, increase insulin level, she can feed her cells with glucose finally.

Feeling energized because of sufficient energy is different from feeling energized because of adrenaline, epinephrine and cortisol. It may not feel different but it is.

I agree, that was a good read.

rightnow
Sun, Feb-24-08, 13:54
I'm a little confused by the 'thin, svelte' comment followed by 'gained back the 2 lbs I had lost'. 2lbs had a 2% increase in her bodyfat %? So her total weight is 100 lbs, but she's allegedly a personal trainer? She'd better be 4'10" in that case if I'm expected to believe she's got a lot of muscle.

The article doesn't lead me to believe that she was one of the brightest stars in the sky to begin with; I am skeptical about all of it.

PJ

KiaKaha
Sun, Feb-24-08, 18:07
Martin, I didnt quite follow what you said about her needing glucose (not technically but comparatively).

I am a non insulin dependent diabetic and I am finding the 25 - 30 carbs a day sufficient to keep me energised apart from occassional patches here and there. Is this because I get glucose from burning fat?

eryalen
Sun, Feb-24-08, 18:31
Sounds like fabricated drivel to me.

M Levac
Sun, Feb-24-08, 19:12
Martin, I didnt quite follow what you said about her needing glucose (not technically but comparatively).

I am a non insulin dependent diabetic and I am finding the 25 - 30 carbs a day sufficient to keep me energised apart from occassional patches here and there. Is this because I get glucose from burning fat?


Too much insulin means lipolysis doesn't start. So when she stops eating carbs, she can't get fatty acids yet because lipolysis doesn't start and she still needs glucose but can't get it because she isn't eating carbs. She's in limbo land waiting for insulin level to drop so lipolysis starts. No energy.

I think she ate so little that she was in starvation mode all along. Maybe not like she was used to during those 22 years of experience. When she resumed eating "balanced", she gained a bit of fat back and gained the energy she wanted. She gained the fat and the energy because she ate enough carbs. Her experience with Atkins is not representative of what should occur. Her conclusions "got rid of high fat foods" means she doesn't understand. It also means she didn't apply the diet properly to get proper conclusion from it to begin with.


Does that make any sense? It's complicated for me too.

joedoro
Sun, Feb-24-08, 22:05
Sorry, but this is just plain silly. BTW how hot does the lemon juice with the Cheyenne pepper have to be in order to cleanse one's blood?

rightnow
Sun, Feb-24-08, 22:39
212 degrees? :lol:













(I know that wasn't what you meant...)