PDA

View Full Version : Pupils to be paid to eat healthy food


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



Demi
Sat, Feb-16-08, 01:36
The Telegraph
London, UK
16 February, 2008


Pupils to be paid to eat healthy food

Children who eat healthy food at school and take regular exercise could receive taxpayer-funded financial bonuses into their state savings accounts, suggests a health adviser to the (British) Government.

The payments into Child Trust Funds would leave healthy teenagers with more cash than their less fit peers when the tax-free policies mature on their 18th birthdays.

Top-ups to the so-called "baby bonds" could be made if parents ensure their children are immunised and cycle to classes.

The idea of putting regular health bonuses into Trust Funds is put forward by Prof Julian le Grand, the chairman of Health England, which advises ministers.

Prof le Grand, who lectures in social policy at the London School of Economics, is advancing a series of other ideas including that smokers should buy a licence - at £10 to £200 - to purchase cigarettes.

A former aide to Tony Blair, Prof le Grand says ministers must act now to create more imaginative, positive incentives to healthy living for all ages if a national health and obesity crisis is to be avoided.

A quarter of children are predicted to be obese by 2050, as well as 60 per cent of men and 50 per cent of women, costing the economy an extra £50 billion a year.

Recent research has shown that Child Trust Funds, which Prof le Grand helped develop, are proving popular with poorer families who are saving for their children's futures. "You could give an extra payment into the Child Trust Fund which is not a direct, crude bribe to the parents, but one that promotes the family, promotes the children and at the same time achieves several government objectives," Prof le Grand told The Daily Telegraph.

Trust Fund top-ups in return for immunisation would be easiest to administer, he said.

But it would also be a "neat solution" if healthy eating at school could be rewarded, perhaps by linking swipe cards used by pupils to buy their food to the bonus scheme. Schemes are already running in some schools where children can accrue points for choosing healthy food, fruit and vegetables at meals which be cashed in for treats such as iPods at the end of term can.

Exercise among young people could also be monitored, perhaps through pedometers or devices attached to bicycles, which would track distances covered.

While the ideas would be difficult to police, and the use of taxpayers' money would inevitably prove controversial, Prof Le Grand insisted the obstacles could be overcome. There are already more than three million young people with Child Trust Funds. The state pays in an initial £250 when the account is opened, with a further £250 if families receive full Child Tax Credit.


http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2008/02/16/nchildren116.xml

ojoj
Sat, Feb-16-08, 02:29
... this is one of the reasons why I have left the UK and now live in Spain! The British government just never think things through. What a complete load of nonsense!!!!

Nancy LC
Sat, Feb-16-08, 08:37
If it were me, when I was a kid, I'd take the money and blow it on junk food and candy. :p

pennink
Sat, Feb-16-08, 09:14
and if they're just putting money into savings accounts, they won't give a crap.

They're KIDS people... gotta have it in the hand before it's real. Instant gratification, yada yada...

morons are running the world.


(not to mention if a kid ordered a high fat low carb meal they'd all freak out)

time2doit
Sat, Feb-16-08, 10:51
Wow, this is a diaster in the planning. When you link an activity that requires internal motivation to maintain (like diet, reading, exercise) to an external reward (like money or gold stars) you REDUCE the liklihood that the person you are trying to manipulate will sustain the activity beyond the rewarded period. In fact, people will rebel at the end of the rewarded period and avoid even pleasurable activities that they have been manipulated into engaging in (like reading, eating healthy, excercise).

Too bad our governments are full of people who like to manipulate other people, rather than thoughtful types.

Wifezilla
Sat, Feb-16-08, 11:25
And people here in the US want to be MORE like the UK. Sheeshh. I need to find a nice 3rd world country without a meddlesome government. Somewhere warm :D

ojoj
Sat, Feb-16-08, 11:36
If it were me, when I was a kid, I'd take the money and blow it on junk food and candy. :p


so would I!!! I think most kids would!

anita45
Sun, Feb-17-08, 02:25
Is this like the ridiculous EMA thing they have for kids in the UK that stay on in education post 16?

I'm a mature student at college and basically most of these kids just take the piss. All they have to do to get the money is have full attendance - I'm not sure how often they get the payments - monthly, termly etc but they have to be marked in by the tutor giving their lesson.

So what do they do? They turn up to the lesson 30-45mins late and still get marked in. Some of them come if for the last 10-15mins.They don't actually do any work and they'll fail their exams but they still get the money...

First of all I don't actually agree with this, but if the government has to do it, shouldn't the incentive be for them to get pass grades (ie A-C and not the ridiculous D, E, F and G grades) and then get the money?

Demi
Sun, Feb-17-08, 02:39
Is this like the ridiculous EMA thing they have for kids in the UK that stay on in education post 16?No it is not like the EMA. The EMA is not given to everyone. It is specifically for 16-19 year old kids from poorer families, those, for example, who would not normally stay on at school due to financial restraints. IMO, that can only be a good thing. I do concede, however, that while it is suppose to be a type of 'grant' to help towards books, travelling costs etc., it may not actually be used in that way.

anita45
Sun, Feb-17-08, 02:58
I am aware of whom the EMAs are directed to - unfortunately it's abused. Throwing money at them doesn't help particularly. What they need is extra support in other forms.

Re the pupils being paid to eat healthily - I don't think it's going to be particularly successful if it is actually implemented.