PDA

View Full Version : NYTimes: How to Boost Your Willpower


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



kyrasdad
Sun, Dec-09-07, 08:35
How to Boost Your Willpower (http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/12/06/how-to-boost-your-willpower/)
Tara Parker-Pope
"Well" Health Blog
December 6, 2007, 11:52 am

Every day, we are tested. Whether it’s a cookie tempting us from our diets or a warm bed coaxing us to sleep late, we are forced to decide between what we want to do and what we ought to do.

The ability to resist our impulses is commonly described as self-control or willpower. The elusive forces behind a person’s willpower have been the subject of increasing scrutiny by the scientific community trying to understand why some people overeat or abuse drugs and alcohol. What researchers are finding is that willpower is essentially a mental muscle, and certain physical and mental forces can weaken or strengthen our self-control.

Studies now show that self-control is a limited resource that may be strengthened by the foods we eat. Laughter and conjuring up powerful memories may also help boost a person’s self-control. And, some research suggests, we can improve self-control through practice, testing ourselves on small tasks in order to strengthen our willpower for bigger challenges.

“Learning self-control produces a wide range of positive outcomes,’’ said Roy Baumeister, a psychology professor at Florida State University who wrote about the issue in this month’s Current Directions in Psychological Science. “Kids do better in school, people do better at work. Look at just about any major category of problem that people are suffering from and odds are pretty good that self-control is implicated in some way.’’

Last month, Dr. Baumeister reported on laboratory studies that showed a relationship between self-control and blood glucose levels. In one study, participants watched a video, but some were asked to suppress smiles and other facial reactions. After the film, blood glucose levels had dropped among those who had exerted self-control to stifle their reactions, but stayed the same among the film watchers who were free to react, according to the report in Personality and Social Psychology Review.

The video watchers were later given a concentration test in which they were asked to identify the color in which words were displayed. The word “red,” for instance, might appear in blue ink. The video watchers who had stifled their responses did the worst on the test, suggesting that their self-control had already been depleted by the film challenge.

But the researchers also found that restoring glucose levels appears to replenish self-control. Study subjects who drank sugar-sweetened lemonade, which raises glucose levels quickly, performed better on self-control tests than those who drank artificially-sweetened beverages, which have no effect on glucose.

The findings make sense because it’s long been known that glucose fuels many brain functions. Having a bite to eat appears to help boost a person’s willpower, and may explain why smokers trying to quit or students trying to focus on studying often turn to food to sustain themselves.

Consuming sugary drinks or snacks isn’t practical advice for a dieter struggling with willpower. However, the research does help explain why dieters who eat several small meals a day appear to do better at sticking to a diet than dieters who skip meals. “You need the energy from food to have the willpower to exert self-control in order to succeed on your diet,'’ said Dr. Baumeister.

Kathleen Vohs, professor of marketing at the University of Minnesota, says that in lab studies, self-control is boosted when people conjure up powerful memories of the things they value in life. Laughter and positive thoughts also help people perform better on self-control tasks. Dr. Vohs notes that self-control problems occur because people are caught up “in the moment’’ and are distracted from their long-term goals.

“You want to look good in a bikini next summer but you’re looking at a piece of chocolate cake now,’’ said Dr. Vohs. “When we get people to think about values we move them to the long-term state, and that cools off the tempting stimuli.’’

Finally, some research suggests that people struggling with self-control should start small. A few studies show that people who were instructed for two weeks to make small changes like improving their posture or brushing their teeth with their opposite hand improved their scores on laboratory tests of self-control. The data aren’t conclusive, but they do suggest that the quest for self-improvement should start small. A vow to stop swearing, to make the bed every day or to give up just one food may be a way to strengthen your self-control, giving you more willpower reserves for bigger challenges later.

“Learning to bring your behavior under control even with arbitrary rules does build character in that it makes you better able to achieve the things you want to achieve later on,'’ said Dr. Baumeister. “Self-control is a limited resource. People make all these different New Year’s resolutions, but they are all pulling off from the same pool of your willpower. It’s better to make one resolution and stick to it than make five.'’

kyrasdad
Sun, Dec-09-07, 08:42
Obviously, low-carbers have discovered the exact opposite: My willpower, such as it is, is sabotaged by eating sugar. In fact, I can't depend on willpower much at all, so I've mostly taken it out of the equation by letting my diet essentially change my desires. I rarely crave sugar anymore.

On the other side, I don't have any other habits that I'm actively otherwise trying to ditch, although I should look at caffeine intake at some point. My perception is that reducing my glucose levels through low carb eating has made my willpower in other areas more robust. I am less distracted and more able to focus. I'm not as annoyed by traffic or other minor annoyances. This is where the advice about students using food to maintain a session rings hollow to me. I am much more able to concentrate now than ever. That could have something to do with being lighter and healthier, but I doubt it. I have more ability to focus now than ever.

But in the arena of food, of course, the notion that eating a bit of sugar will restore your willpower is pure foolishness. Sugar is sugar's own gateway drug.

oakdryad
Sun, Dec-09-07, 09:17
For me, I find that my willpower is strengthened by eating something with yummy fat in it. If I'm pleasantly full with something that has butter or cream or a full fat cheese in it, I'm just not that tempted by the carby stuff and it's easy to take a pass. :D

Zei
Sun, Dec-09-07, 18:00
I'm tired and cranky when hungry (presumably my blood sugar is low then?) and that of course makes every kind of thinking probably including self-control, concentrating studying or otherwise all hard. But I eat fat and protein to bring it up, not sugar. So I'm thinking there's some good facts in this article, just the typical bad ideas due to misunderstanding on how to refuel your brain and body.

pennink
Sun, Dec-09-07, 18:46
This has GOT to be funded in some part by sugar lobbyists or something similar. What the heck????

Where on earth do they dig up this trash? Most people who have trouble are insulin resistant in most cases, and this is basically giving them permission to fall off the New Year's resolution wagon.

honestly... my willpower comes from the high I get from wearing smaller pants and getting compliments from those I love! from sugar.. oh for Pete's sake...

LessLiz
Sun, Dec-09-07, 18:56
This has GOT to be funded in some part by sugar lobbyists or something similar. What the heck????Not really -- there are an awful lot of stupid people in this world, some of whom are quite creative. ;)

pennink
Sun, Dec-09-07, 19:00
Not really -- there are an awful lot of stupid people in this world, some of whom are quite creative. ;)


that just brought out a giant guffaw... :lol: yeah, what next? Add corn to all meals for heart disease and to end obesity...

mike_d
Sun, Dec-09-07, 19:53
Study subjects who drank sugar-sweetened lemonade, which raises glucose levels quickly, performed better on self-control tests than those who drank artificially-sweetened beverages, which have no effect on glucose.Problem here: AF sweeteners can cause an insulin response in many people with a subsequent even lower blood sugar drop than if no sweetener was consumed.

ValerieL
Mon, Dec-10-07, 09:14
Problem here: AF sweeteners can cause an insulin response in many people with a subsequent even lower blood sugar drop than if no sweetener was consumed.

There are studies disputing this.

http://www.ajcn.org/cgi/content/full/82/5/1011

At least in beverages, it seems that sweet taste & nutritive content are needed for the cephalic phase insulin response.

PS Diva
Mon, Dec-10-07, 15:16
It looks to me as if the study measures willpower immediately after the ingestion of sugar. Not an hour or two later when your blood sugar levels have crashed. I'm betting that the subjects dosed with sugar would perform worse than the controls at that point!

kaypeeoh
Mon, Dec-10-07, 15:48
A few days ago NPR had a special on brain function as relates to memory and aging. Memory requires hyperplasticity of neurons. That is, the more neorons that are firing as you try to memorise something, the better the odds of keeping the memory.

That has nothing to do with this topic but I can make a connection. When you're learning something as I said, neurons are being formed and connections are made. The higher the number of connections, the longer the memory will survive. The same effect explains bad habits, like eating when there's no real hunger. If you've had a habit of eating cookies before bedtime the habit forces you to want to continue it. You've formed intense neuron connections that expect to fire at the same time each night. It has little to do with blood sugar. It's the result of long-term habit. The longer the habit, the higher the number of active neurons.

What I found is realizing that it's a quirk of my mind makes it much easier to not head for the cookie jar at 10:00 PM. I know I'm not hungry but out of habit I tend to have cookies before bedtime. Knowing that my mind is still able to form connections because of hyperplasticity makes it much easier to ignore the urge to eat cookies at night.