PDA

View Full Version : Lose that belly boys, eat red meat: scientific study


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



tamarian
Fri, Dec-07-07, 08:51
Lose that belly boys, eat red meat: scientific study

A new study conducted by Australia's Commonwealth Science and Industrial Research Organization has found that overweight and obese men can strip inches off their waist-line and lose weight effectively and safely on a high protein red meat diet. In fact, a balanced red meat diet was found to be better for tightening the belt buckle than a balanced carb diet.

Presenting the results of the study today at the Nutrition Society Conference in Auckland, NZ, CSIRO dietitian Dr Manny Noakes said that the study suggests it is easier than previously thought for men to take action to lose weight.

The study compared a diet high in protein, red meat and fibre with one high in carbohydrate and fibre, finding that both diets led to similar weight losses, but the high protein diet was more effective at reducing abdominal fat levels.

"Abdominal fat is a key risk factor for men for a range of diseases including colorectal and other cancers," Dr Noakes said.

"The results also show that a range of indicators of bowel, kidney and bone health showed no difference between the high protein diet and the high carbohydrate diet.

"For weight loss, red meat and other protein sources should be eaten as part of a balanced eating plan."

The findings of the study back-up the long held contention of male and female body builders that high protein and low carb diets are best for keeping excess body fat to a minimum.

The study was initiated by CSIRO as part of the Preventative Health National Research Flagship and partly financially supported by Meat and Livestock Australia. Over 100 overweight and obese men participated in the study.

National Research Flagships. www.csiro.au/flagships CSIRO initiated the National Research Flagships to provide science-based solutions in response to Australia's major research challenges and opportunities. The nine Flagships form multidisciplinary teams with industry and the research community to deliver impact and benefits for Australia.

http://www.itwire.com/content/view/15668/1066/

Dodger
Fri, Dec-07-07, 09:01
While I like the conclusions, I'm always skeptical about results that benefit the sponsor, "financially supported by Meat and Livestock Australia".

confession
Fri, Dec-07-07, 09:05
It would be interesting to know if the findings also apply to some women who tend to have extra internal abdominal fat.(apple shape) I would tend to think so, but obviously one cannot assume.

Thanks for posting this.

eryalen
Fri, Dec-07-07, 09:31
While I like the conclusions, I'm always skeptical about results that benefit the sponsor, "financially supported by Meat and Livestock Australia".
That would include 98% of sponsored studies.

bike2work
Fri, Dec-07-07, 10:01
Oops ... never mind.

ReginaW
Fri, Dec-07-07, 10:08
While I like the conclusions, I'm always skeptical about results that benefit the sponsor, "financially supported by Meat and Livestock Australia".

CISRO in Australia depends a lot on money from industry for their research...(sigh)

Angeline
Fri, Dec-07-07, 15:54
We will never have bias free studies. Research institutes, and universities have grown too addicted to grant money from big corporations, and the governement is too cheap to pay for it all.

But at least in this case they are disclosing this information. And it's nice to see the meat industry defending itself after being maligned for so long.

Let's not forget that the ADA is supported in large part by manufacturers of highly processed and refined carbs products.

Who knows, if various interest groups keep slinging accusations of bias at each other, maybe more attention will be paid to bias and researchers won't get away with fudging their conclusions so much. And maybe they really is a Santa Claus. <sigh>

LC FP
Fri, Dec-07-07, 15:57
CISRO in Australia depends a lot on money from industry for their research...(sigh
Maybe Regina, but Manny Noakes is a real scientist and a skeptic of LC. I remember her at the conference disbelieving one of the posters showing resolution of fatty liver with a LC diet...