PDA

View Full Version : Diet fad threat to kids


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



bsheets
Sat, Aug-25-07, 21:10
Diet fad threat to kids

Suellen Hinde
August 12, 2007

A 10-DAY detox diet consisting of only lemon juice, water and tree sap syrup is being sold to children as young as six.

The popularity of the Lemon Detox Diet has soared in Australia, with more than 40,000 sales through the internet in the past six months.

It has become a hot diet/cleansing treatment for Hollywood celebrities such as Angelina Jolie.

Nutritionist Rosemary Stanton is "horrified" by the cleansing diet.

"There really isn't any proof this works," Dr Stanton said.

"It is quite hazardous to put children on something that is unproven.

"Children are growing and their bodies need protein. A diet like that will force their bodies to break down their own body protein.

"It is dangerous and the wrong way to go."

The diet was designed by Hawaiian naturopath Stanley Burroughs 30 years ago.

It involves drinking nothing more than a mixture of fresh lemon juice, cayenne, water and Madal Bal Natural Tree Syrup for seven to 10 days.

The syrup is being sold through the internet for $79 a bottle.

The Australian distributor, Sydney-based Andre Saade, said the product was suitable for children, while the company's website states it is "absolutely" safe for children. The syrup is made from the sap of trees -- one part maple, five parts south-east palm syrup, and tastes sweet and sour. Dr Stanton said the internet was not the place to go for health advice.

"People are simply spending money on something that they are not sure works," she said.

"The body has its own detox system and that is the liver and the kidneys."

http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,21985,22225020-24331,00.html

PghLady74
Sun, Aug-26-07, 19:55
This is scary but, What 6 year old is able to buy a $79 bottle of syrup through the internet? :confused:

ruthla
Sun, Aug-26-07, 20:14
There's probably nothing wrong with kids drinking this lemonade- as long as it's in addition to other foods, not in place of them. That's probably the context in which the "safe for kids" comment was originallly made.

For adults, used for up to 10 days at a time, it's probably also safe- assuming it's followed by a healthy eating plan that includes plenty of protein.

If somebody tried to subsist on nothing but lemonade long term there would be health problems, but it's not intended for that purpose.

potatofree
Sun, Aug-26-07, 20:46
Ruthla- it specifies that the plan consists ONLY of the drink.

CVH
Mon, Aug-27-07, 03:29
Can't be any worse than what most kids are doing now.....

Mousesmom
Mon, Aug-27-07, 07:42
This is scary but, What 6 year old is able to buy a $79 bottle of syrup through the internet? :confused:


What about those crazy parents who will actually buy it for their kids? And then make them drink it because the parents think the kid is fat!

JMHO but that would border on child abuse to me....

If the kid (or adult) needs to eat healthier and get to a healthy weight removing food and starving isn't going to help. It will only teach an unhealthy attitude towards food and reinforce the poor body image and low self esteem.

Julie

PghLady74
Mon, Aug-27-07, 08:27
What about those crazy parents who will actually buy it for their kids? And then make them drink it because the parents think the kid is fat!

JMHO but that would border on child abuse to me....

If the kid (or adult) needs to eat healthier and get to a healthy weight removing food and starving isn't going to help. It will only teach an unhealthy attitude towards food and reinforce the poor body image and low self esteem.

Julie
Totally agreed!!

Squarecube
Mon, Aug-27-07, 09:20
Diet fad threat to kids

snip

Dr Stanton said the internet was not the place to go for health advice.

snip

http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,21985,22225020-24331,00.html

Well, er, yes and no.

scthgharpy
Mon, Aug-27-07, 11:25
Angelina jolie? Well that explains why she has NO muscle tone any more, looks like a skeleton. Does anyone remember when she looked strong?