PDA

View Full Version : Basic Heart Rate Monitor - can't find!!!


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



Surface9
Mon, Jun-11-07, 06:18
I still have my very OLD Polar heart rate monitor, but the
wrist unit is starting to fail - it was very basic and only
read out the heart rate (beats per minute) in non-flashing big
led numbers and it started as soon as you wetted the sending
unit and placed it snug against your bare chest. No buttons,
no confusing features - just a basic continuous non-flashing
readout of your heart rate.

I can't find anything like that anymore - not even at POLAR
- they all brag about "features, features, features"
time-of-day, average this and that, and who knows what all
kinds of nonsense that just confuse you when ALL you want to
to quickly look at your wrist and see a readout of your
heart rate.

Last week I purshaced a Polar and everytime I look at it, it
is either telling me the time, or some stupid stopwatch, or
who knows what, and, I have to stop, punch it to go off, punch
it again to start again, and then wait a few seconds for it to
finally read out my heart rate - by the time I get to see my
heart rate it has naturally slowed down because of all the
rigamorow I have to go through before I get to see the number.

Then I contunue my workout and, anytime I look at my wrist to
check it again, it is no longer reading out my heartrate but
giving me some other stupid feature and I am back to having to
turn it off and go through that nonsense all over again. I
emailed Polar and they just ignored me.

DOES ANYONE make a basic no-nonsense wrist-chest heart rate
monitor anymore? Like the basic kind Polar USED TO MAKE??????

All I want is to wet the sender, strap it onto my chest, strap
on the wrist unit, hold it next to my chest for a few seconds,
and then start my workout and not have to do anything else but
occassionally take a quick glance at my wrist and see a big
solid number (non-flashing) that reflects my heart rate at
that time. I know this is possible becuase I bought this one
less than 4 years ago but the wrist unit quit working recently
and I can't find one just like that anymore - blast! Why do
companies have to "improve" what are very good products and
just make a mess of things - why can't they keep on making the
basic things like that basic dedicated heart rate monitor?

This is very frustrating!

Joe Doe
Mon, Jun-11-07, 06:18
In article
<1181520298.563784.172950@w5g2000hsg.googlegroups.com>,
surface9 <davsf@neto.com> wrote:

> DOES ANYONE make a basic no-nonsense wrist-chest heart rate
> monitor anymore? Like the basic kind Polar USED TO
> MAKE??????
>
Why do companies have to "improve" what are very good products
> and just make a mess of things - why can't they keep on
> making the basic things like that basic dedicated heart rate
> monitor?
>
> This is very frustrating!

Look for a Polar F1 or FS1 monitor.

http://www.amazon.com/F1-Heart-Rate-Monitor-Transmitter/dp/B0-
007YD9R0/ref =pd_bbs_sr_5/104-2160556-4331958?ie=UTF8&s=hpc&q-
id=1181525387&sr=8-5

http://www.amazon.com/Polar-Heart-Rate-Monitor-Watch/dp/B000A-
SDGU8/ref=pd _bbs_sr_1/104-2160556-4331958?ie=UTF8&s=sporting-
-goods&qid=1181525387&sr= 8-1

Roland

Joeu2004
Mon, Jun-11-07, 06:18
On Jun 10, 5:04 pm, surface9 <d...@neto.com> wrote:
> Last week I purshaced a Polar and everytime I look at it, it
> is either telling me the time, or some stupid stopwatch
> [...]. I have to stop, punch it to go off, punch it again to
> start again, and then wait a few seconds for it to finally
> read out my heart rate [....] Then I contunue my workout
> and, anytime I look at my wrist to check it again, it is no
> longer reading out my heartrate but giving me some other
> stupid feature and I am back to having to turn it off and go
> through that nonsense all over again.

That would bother me, too. What model are you talking about?

I find it hard to believe that you cannot put it into
continuous HRM mode. That is a big selling point with Polar.
It is emphasized on its web site.

I have to replace my A1 soon because the seal has decayed.
Even the A1 requires that you turn it on to use it, and there
is a 5-sec delay. But once it is on, it stays on as long as
the transmitter is in range.

Even when the transmitter goes out of range, the A1 stays on.
It reports the HR as soon as the transmitter comes back in
range. So I suppose you could leave it on all the time. Not
sure what that does for the receiver battery; but at least
that is easy to replace.

Surface9
Mon, Jun-11-07, 17:17
On Jun 10, 9:13 pm, joeu2004 <joeu2...@hotmail.com> wrote:
> On Jun 10, 5:04 pm, surface9 <d...@neto.com> wrote:
>
> > Last week I purshaced a Polar and everytime I look at it,
> > it is either telling me the time, or some stupid stopwatch
> > [...]. I have to stop, punch it to go off, punch it again
> > to start again, and then wait a few seconds for it to
> > finally read out my heart rate [....] Then I contunue my
> > workout and, anytime I look at my wrist to check it again,
> > it is no longer reading out my heartrate but giving me
> > some other stupid feature and I am back to having to turn
> > it off and go through that nonsense all over again.
>
> That would bother me, too. What model are you talking about?
>
> I find it hard to believe that you cannot put it into
> continuous HRM mode. That is a big selling point with Polar.
> It is emphasized on its web site.
>
> I have to replace my A1 soon because the seal has decayed.
> Even the A1 requires that you turn it on to use it, and
> there is a 5-sec delay. But once it is on, it stays on as
> long as the transmitter is in range.
>
> Even when the transmitter goes out of range, the A1 stays
> on. It reports the HR as soon as the transmitter comes back
> in range. So I suppose you could leave it on all the time.
> Not sure what that does for the receiver battery; but at
> least that is easy to replace.

My unit is the FS1 - the least "feature-rich" of the ones they
had at Walmart. I got it because it said on the box
"continuous heart rate", but, that is A LIE. When I finally
get it to start reading out my heart rate, it is flashing and
I can't just glance at it and read my heart rate - and, I
don't know why, but, after a while (since I am exercising and
not watching it continuosly), it starts reading the time or
something else - could be the moving around of my arm or who
knows, but, this unit is worthless and a complete WASTE OF
MONEY AND TIME. And Polar doesn't care to deal with an
unsatisfied customer - typical modern business jerks.

>From looking over the offerings on amazon (from the replies
>here), it
appears that NO ONE offers the basic model anymore - that is,
I can find not a single offering that consists SOLELY of a
heart rate monitor with NO BUTTONS, NO OPTIONS, and no timer,
average this or that, or anything else. The old one I have is
the polar beat, I think. If I can get a new battery for that,
then that is what I would like to do,

Why doesn't somebody make one like that anymore? Nuts!