PDA

View Full Version : Take Food Claims With a Grain of Salt


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



Judynyc
Thu, Feb-22-07, 14:33
Take Food Claims With a Grain of Salt

Most people make an effort to eat healthful food, at least some of the time. Some shoppers are vigilant about making the healthiest food choices and carefully read the nutrition information of every food label.

Others take a more casual approach to healthful eating simply by adding vegetables, fruits and lean protein to their diet. Even people who overindulge on junk food generally report that they would like to start eating a healthier diet.

Even if you are striving to have a healthful diet, it can be a challenge to determine which foods are the best choices. The vast array of information available can be confusing to most shoppers. The marketplace bombards us with new diet plans that have very different theories about the types of foods we should be eating.

I remember years ago that "smart dieters" selected very low-fat diets in favor of higher carbohydrate choices. We bought"low-fat cookies that ended up having far more sugar (and more calories) than the original version of the cookies.

The Atkins Diet took the opposite approach, promoting a low- carbohydrate, high-fat approach. The South Beach Diet took the middle road by emphasizing a low-carbohydrate, lower-fat approach. Programs such as Weight Watchers advocate a more flexible eating plan that includes a moderate amount of all food groups.

Still other diet plans advocate choosing organic and natural food to avoid undesirable chemicals and pesticides.

To further confuse shoppers, food manufacturers change their food labels frequently to keep up with the latest trends. During the South Beach and Atkins diet crazes, many food products began to carry the "low-carb" label. Even products that had always been low in carbohydrates (such as salad dressings that are high in fat) began to tout their low-carb attributes.

More recently, hundreds of food manufacturers changed product recipes and began labeling their products with the "zero trans fat" label as we learned that trans fats are unhealthy. Two years ago, I had never even heard of trans fats.

It came as no surprise when I read recent consumer behavior findings collected by Kraft Foods. Irene Rosenfeld, an officer of Kraft Foods, reported at a food industry conference in January that consumers are so confused by rapidly changing food health claims that they are ignoring them altogether and resorting to common sense.

The sheer volume of food health claims confuses them, and the fact that many food health claims are later refuted by new research forces them to ignore health claims completely.

As a result of conflicting messages, shoppers begin to think that all food health claims are fads and are not worth following. Ms. Rosenfeld's recommendation to industry peers was that companies needed to work together so that clear and consistent information is presented on packages, in stores and in advertising messages. Consumers can then make informed choices about whether they wish to consume a certain product.

I would take her recommendation a step further and suggest that shoppers become more educated from other health information sources, and study the food companies' claims with a close eye. Understandably, food companies will use health claims that favor their products and will leave out the unhealthful details of their products.

For example, if a product is a low-carbohydrate product, the label will tout that fact, but probably will not mention that it is a high-fat product. Many diet frozen entrees display low calorie counts prominently on the front label, but high sodium contents are in fine print on the back label.

As smart shoppers, we need to take the time to read the fine print, and the prominent health claims, to make sure we are buying products that meet our dietary goals.





STEPHANIE NELSON SHARES HER SAVINGS TIPS AS A REGULAR CONTRIBUTOR ON ABC NEWS' GOOD MORNING AMERICA. YOU CAN FIND MORE OF HER SAVINGS TIPS IN HER BOOK THE GREATEST SECRETS OF THE COUPON MOM AND ON HER WEB SITE, WWW.COUPONMOM.COM. SHE CAN BE REACHED AT SHOPPINGMOM~UNITEDMEDIA.COM.

(c) 2007 Augusta Chronicle, The. Provided by ProQuest Information and Learning. All rights Reserved.



Source: Augusta Chronicle, The




http://www.redorbit.com:80/news/health/849818/take_food_claims_with_a_grain_of_salt/index.html?source=r_health

Dodger
Thu, Feb-22-07, 15:17
Good article. One thing that was not mentioned was the various endorsements from health groups that are put on foods by manufactures who have paid a fee to the group. The AHA has their 'Heart-Healthy' logo and the ADA has logo to put on foods.

ReginaW
Thu, Feb-22-07, 15:35
Good article. One thing that was not mentioned was the various endorsements from health groups that are put on foods by manufactures who have paid a fee to the group. The AHA has their 'Heart-Healthy' logo and the ADA has logo to put on foods.

Oh come on Dodger, you mean Lucky Charms and Coco Puffs really aren't heart healthy? Damn! :cry:

gryfonclaw
Thu, Feb-22-07, 17:00
Oh come on Dodger, you mean Lucky Charms and Coco Puffs really aren't heart healthy? Damn! :cry:


Do I wish.

bkloots
Thu, Feb-22-07, 17:34
And even after we get committed to the low-carb lifestyle and take the fresh foods path, we start thinking about hormone-infused meat, antibiotic tainted eggs, nutrient-deficient, pesticide-coated vegetables...the list goes on.

Hate to tell ya...we're all going to die. :angel:

Sigh. I'm doing the best I can.

Wyvrn
Thu, Feb-22-07, 18:51
As smart shoppers, we need to take the time to read the fine printIt's really a lot less complicated than that. If I see "fine print" on the label, I just don't buy it.

probiotic
Thu, Feb-22-07, 18:57
It's really a lot less complicated than that. If I see "fine print" on the label, I just don't buy it.

And sadly, also, if you see an ADA or AHA endorsement on the packaging you can be pretty sure it is high carb and full of junk.

brobin
Thu, Feb-22-07, 20:18
I stopped listening to health claims when Twizzlers started bragging about being low in fat.. but you can't but low carb on a label in Canada...

Twizzlers, the healthy, low fat snack... /barf

2bthinner!
Thu, Feb-22-07, 21:15
And most of it doesn't even have real licorice. :lol:

http://www.hersheys.com/nutrition/licorice.asp

Licorice and Glycyrrhizic Acid
Licorice Candy
True licorice candy contains an extract from the root of the licorice plant, Glycyrrhiza glabra. This licorice root has been used since ancient times to flavor and sweeten candies, teas, throat lozenges, pharmaceuticals, and other products. Today many, but not all, black licorice candies are flavored with licorice extract.

Glycyrrhizic Acid
Licorice root extract contains glycyrrhizic acid. Glycyrrhizic acid can affect the body's use of an adrenal gland hormone that helps to regulate sodium and water balance. Reports in the medical literature have indicated that excessive consumption of true black licorice, for example, about 3-1/2 ounces a day for several months can adversely affect sodium and water balance. This especially may occur in individuals who are predisposed to conditions such as edema hypertension (high blood pressure or fluid retention).

Licorice-Type Products
HERSHEY'S makes many licorice-type products that do not contain glycyrrhizic acid. TWIZZLERS Candy are often called licorice but only the black versions contain licorice extract. The other versions do not contain licorice extract and are not true licorice candies.

ETA: I find it kinda funny that the AHA, American Heart Association has an acronym of discovery. But... :lol:

Judynyc
Fri, Feb-23-07, 08:28
IMO, the general population falls way to easily to the hype created by packaged food compnaies. People really do need to learn how to read ingredient labels and what they are acutally saying.

Kraft and the South Beach Diet people did not do anyone any favors, except themselves, by producing a line of SBD foods. I see too many people thinking they are doing SBD by eating their packaged foods!! :daze: Their line of foods barely represent what SBD is really about....which is eaitng whole, fresh and as unprocessed as possible.

The SBD is based on the GI of carbs and processing raises the GI of any carb. The more the processing, the higher the GI. :idea:

Maybe Kraft needs to figure out the GI of their packaged foods and put THAT on the package too. ;)

Squarecube
Fri, Feb-23-07, 09:47
Take Food Claims With a Grain of Salt

[snip] Two years ago, I had never even heard of trans fats.

[snip]

STEPHANIE NELSON SHARES HER SAVINGS TIPS AS A REGULAR CONTRIBUTOR ON ABC NEWS' GOOD MORNING AMERICA.
http://www.redorbit.com:80/news/health/849818/take_food_claims_with_a_grain_of_salt/index.html?source=r_health

If two years ago she never heard of trans fat, what qualifies her to be paid by ABC News Good Morning America to parrot what Kraft food says and to lecture to us about hidden fat and salt. Grrrrr.

renegadiab
Fri, Feb-23-07, 09:58
I am new to the forum and a type 2 diabetic who has been on low carb for about 10 months. Not only has it improved my glucose control, it has enabled me to lose more weight than I ever did on Weight Watchers or any other low fat approach.

I recently looked at a box of "Take Heart" Quaker Instant Oatmeal, with the AHA logo of course. It had 9 grams of sugar per serving. Sugar was the second ingredient listed and it included blueberries sweetened with HFCS. Yeah, really heart healthy. :lol:

As for South Beach products, I was glad to see that South Beach Ranch Dressing didn't have any added sugar and thought I had found a good brand of salad dressing. SURPRISE, some of their other dressings do have added sugar. I'm not on the South Beach diet, but I thought that sugar was at least highly discouraged on it.

ysabella
Fri, Feb-23-07, 14:39
renegadiab, welcome! :)

The main thing that eating low-carb has done for me is, take me far, far away from most packaged products. I'll buy the yuppie packaged vegetables for convenience, and I buy some canned goods (canned tomatoes, coconut milk, tetra paks of stock), but mostly I'm shopping around the edges of the store and in the 'natural foods' section. :thup:

And most of it doesn't even have real licorice. :lol:
Try the nothern European stuff sometime - like Dutch drop or salmiak. It's intense. It's not even always sweet, sometimes it's salty instead. A Dutch friend handed me a salmiak (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salmiakki) lollipop once, and I was expecting something sweet - BLAMMO! :eek:

waywardsis
Fri, Feb-23-07, 17:46
Same here ysabella - I don't worry much about fine print when I'm not eating much packaged stuff. Still, I have become a label detective ;)

Judynyc
Fri, Feb-23-07, 21:27
I am new to the forum and a type 2 diabetic who has been on low carb for about 10 months. Not only has it improved my glucose control, it has enabled me to lose more weight than I ever did on Weight Watchers or any other low fat approach.

I recently looked at a box of "Take Heart" Quaker Instant Oatmeal, with the AHA logo of course. It had 9 grams of sugar per serving. Sugar was the second ingredient listed and it included blueberries sweetened with HFCS. Yeah, really heart healthy. :lol:

As for South Beach products, I was glad to see that South Beach Ranch Dressing didn't have any added sugar and thought I had found a good brand of salad dressing. SURPRISE, some of their other dressings do have added sugar. I'm not on the South Beach diet, but I thought that sugar was at least highly discouraged on it.

Welcome!! :wave:

Congrats on your loss. :thup:

As for South Beach discouraging the use of sugar, yes, it is a big :nono: That is why it bothers me that the Kraft compnay has produced a line of foods that contains sugar and not just a little bit either :eek: . :devil:

So many think people that because it has the SBD name on it, then it must be good...but its not...and I too have become a label detective. ;)

I make my own dressing and have tried one of the SBD frozen pizzas...not so great :thdown: I'd much rather enjoy the real thing at my local thin crust pizza place...as a treat once in a while.

bkloots
Sat, Feb-24-07, 06:24
I too have become a label detective If I'm ever tempted by anything in a wrapper or box or package, I simply read the fine print on the label. Stops me every time.