PDA

View Full Version : McKeith’s diet plan is snubbed by ministers


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



Demi
Mon, Jan-01-07, 05:33
The Times
London, UK
Published 31 December, 2006



MINISTERS (Scottish Government Ministers) have snubbed an offer by Gillian McKeith, the diet guru, to lead an anti-obesity campaign in Scotland.

The Perthshire-born presenter of Channel 4’s You Are What You Eat (http://www.channel4.com/entertainment/tv/microsites/Y/yawye/apply.html), has offered to head a healthy eating taskforce which she claims could transform the country’s appalling dietary habits.

Under her plan “hit squads” of nutritionists would be sent into obese households to give dietary advice and wean families off junk food.

McKeith also calls for nutrition lessons to become part of the primary school curriculum and for parents to be offered tax breaks to complete healthy eating courses.

However, her offer to help tackle Scotland’s obesity epidemic has already been rejected by ministers, who claim that healthy eating campaigns are working despite mounting evidence to the contrary.

Scotland has one of the highest levels of obesity in the developed world. More than one in five of Scots adults are obese, while more than a third of 12-year-olds are overweight, a fifth are obese and one in 10 is severely obese.

Earlier this year a 16-year-old girl who weighed 34 stone had life-saving surgery at Glasgow’s Gartnavel hospital to be fitted with a gastric band to limit her food intake.

McKeith said: “We are talking about a lot of disenfranchised people who have not got the education. These people need to be re-educated and the only way to do that is to have a plan of action funded by the government.”

She wants to use schools as a focus by setting up night classes in nutrition. McKeith believes offering tax breaks to parents who complete the course successfully would act as a powerful incentive.

“In one school a couple of years ago,” she said, “ I created a parent-teacher-pupil monthly meeting, where people talked about food and exchanged ideas. Speakers were brought in and it helped the parents to understand what a healthy regime for a child really is.”

McKeith, whose TV programme regularly attracts 3m viewers, said she was confident that she could deliver a dramatic improvement in Scotland’s dietary habits and will submit her plan to ministers in the new year regardless.

Over the past decade £100m has been spent on healthy living campaigns in Scotland, including providing free fruit in primary schools and removing junk food from school vending machines. But fresh fruit and vegetable consumption has declined and obesity rates continue to rise.

Dr Nanette Milne, health spokeswoman for the Scottish Conservatives, said: “Gillian McKeith’s ideas seem very sensible and I would have thought the executive would at the very least have wanted to explore them.”

A Scottish executive spokeswoman said: “We are always grateful for offers of assistance such as Dr McKeith’s, but we already have a comprehensive strategy to tackle obesity and a full range of expert advice on diet and nutrition.”


http://www.timesonline.co.uk/newspaper/0,,176-2524820,00.html

Dawn Renee
Thu, Feb-01-07, 10:31
I'm glad to see the ministers have some sense.

Has anyone been watching Ms McKeith's latest series? Her browbeating and insults have gotten worse, but on top of that, has anyone else noticed how completely unhealthy she looks herself? Yes, she's thin, but she's also haggard, pale, wrinkly, and bony. She has also completely lost the ability to smile, and looks as if she's in misery most of the time.

Get this woman a cheeseburger, please.

Plus, she's NOT a doctor - she has no formal accreditation (cite http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gillian_mckeith ). While some (certainly not all!) of her ideas are good, she's not got the credentials to back them up. Why should the Ministry of Health listen to her?

I live in Scotland, and we DEFINATELY have a problem here with obesity. But she's not the saviour to fix it!

Angeline
Thu, Feb-01-07, 11:34
I've watched her shows many times and I've noticed the same thing. She looks old. I suspect she is a vegan. She often has a very anti-meat stance and forces her hapless "patients" to go vegan for their weight loss period.

She is also anti-fat. She rants about "artery-clogging" fat.

Her only saving grace in my book is that she is anti junk-food and anti processed carbs.

Micha2
Fri, Feb-02-07, 08:29
Yes, she looks definitely scrawny...

And she is terrified of catching germs. When she stayed over at someone's house, she slept in her sleeping bag on top of the bed clothes so she wouldn't have to get in contact with someone else's hair, etc. Way over the top.

In the last show she said an excessive consumption of saturated fat could lead to liver cirrhosis and even cancer. I thought that topped it all.

Not sure if she is vegan though. For some people she does recommend oily fish, so I am wondering if she eats fish.