PDA

View Full Version : Sugar Linked with Mental Problems in Teens


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



Rosebud
Thu, Oct-05-06, 17:26
http://www.smh.com.au/news/childrens-health/sugar-linked-with-mental-problems/2006/10/05/1159641445721.html

Teens who drank the most sugary soft drinks also had more mental health problems such as hyperactivity and distress, Norwegian researchers have reported.

Their study of more than 5,000 Norwegian 15- and 16-year-olds showed a clear and direct association between soft drink intake and hyperactivity, and a more complex link with other mental and behavioural disorders.

They surveyed the students, asking them how many fizzy soft drinks with sugar they had a day, and then questions from a standard questionnaire used to assess mental health.

The teens who reported skipping breakfast and lunch were among the heaviest soft drink consumers, Dr. Lars Lien and colleagues at the University of Oslo found.

"There was a strong association between soft drink consumption and mental health problems among Oslo 10th graders," they wrote in their report, published in the American Journal of Public Health.

"This association remained significant after adjustment for social, behavioural and food-related disorders."

Most of the students said they drank anywhere between one and six servings of soft drinks per week.

Those who drank no soft drinks at all were more likely than moderate drinkers to have mental health symptoms, the researchers said. But those who drank the most - more than six servings a week - had the highest scores.

For hyperactivity, there was a direct linear relationship - the more sodas a teen drank, the most symptoms of hyperactivity he or she had.

The worst problems were seen in boys and girls who drank four or more soft drinks a day. Ten per cent of the boys and 2 per cent of the girls drank this much.

The researchers said it was possible that other substances in the soft drinks, such as caffeine, were to blame for the symptoms, and they did not check other possible sources of refined sugar in the children's diets.

But they said many of the teens were clearly drinking too many sugary drinks. Norway's recommended intake is 10 per cent of the day's total calories from sugar and the researchers said at least a quarter of the boys were getting this much from soft drinks alone.

"One simple and effective measure to reduce soft drink consumption in this age group would be to remove soft drink machines from schools and other public places where adolescents gather," they wrote.

ItsTheWooo
Thu, Oct-05-06, 17:34
I do think sugar contributes to mental/behavioral problems particularly in children, but this study didn't control all relevant variables so it is hard to tell.

Kids drinking a lot of soft drinks and skipping breakfast are also at risk for the following:
- deprivation of essential fats/proteins and overall poor nutrition
- poor guidance; poor family environment, negligence

These factors can influence mental health in children a lot more than sugar can.

GeorgeMead
Fri, Oct-06-06, 02:51
Kids drinking a lot of soft drinks and skipping breakfast are also at risk for the following:
- deprivation of essential fats/proteins and overall poor nutrition
- poor guidance; poor family environment, negligence

These factors can influence mental health in children a lot more than sugar can. I had a personal experience that convinced me that there is a significant biological factor that should be studied in a rigorous scientific way. For a year I car pooled with a friend. When we arrived at his home I frequently would stay for a few beers, (a few too many, sometimes). His 5yo grandson was a soda addict. I would buy sugar free soda to share with him so I was not embarrassed by our drinking beer while offering him nothing. His grandfather noticed that his behavior was significantly better when he was given sugar free soda, he would literally bounce off the walls when he got into the “real stuff”. While there are legitimate arguments against artificial sweeteners as well, there is no doubt in my mind that enormous doses of liquid candy are harmfull.

ojoj
Fri, Oct-06-06, 06:52
there is no doubt in my mind that sugar is just another nasty, addictive drug!!

tom sawyer
Fri, Oct-06-06, 08:18
Cause and effect are tough to distinguish here. It seems more likely to me, that these people are simply self-medicating by over-indulging in these sugary drinks. Seems that I've read where the same group also tends to abuse drugs more often, and they don't blame the condition on the drugs.

arc
Fri, Oct-06-06, 08:18
My oldest boy (age 12) is prone to be unstable when he eats too many carbs. He will have violent mood swings and will lash out in uncontrollable anger. He gets very scared when this happens, because he says he can't control it. If we keep the carbs down and make sure that he eats fat and protein for breakfast, he is much more even-keeled.

It doesn't appear to affect my youngest son the same way, though.

tom sawyer
Fri, Oct-06-06, 08:25
I'm not saying there isn't an effect of carbs on kids with these behavioral problems. I'm sure that they are after the short "high" you get from eating sugar, and the subsequent crash is only amplified in them.

But I do think the underlying causes, are neurological and not nutritional. Otherwise we'd see a much higher incidence since MOST kids re getting tons of sugar and crap.

arc
Fri, Oct-06-06, 08:34
Otherwise we'd see a much higher incidence since MOST kids re getting tons of sugar and crap.

You apparently haven't been in a school lately.

tom sawyer
Fri, Oct-06-06, 10:40
My wife teaches high school.

Good point. hehe

Azlocarb
Sat, Oct-07-06, 07:55
My cousin was one of those kids that today would be a ridlin zombie. He was a pretty normal kid lots of energy until you gave him a soda(back then they had real sugar in them not HFCS) then he would go nuts and drive my Ant crazy. So, just from that experience I have to say that some kids should be kept away from sugar or any refined carbs.

pennink
Sat, Oct-07-06, 08:36
"Those who drank no soft drinks at all were more likely than moderate drinkers to have mental health symptoms, the researchers said. But those who drank the most - more than six servings a week - had the highest scores."


Soo.... they're damned if they do, and damned if they don't? This doesn't make sense.

My daughter has never ever drank soda (she's a teen). She's the only one in most classes who can stay focused through a class, and has no acne--none.

I was addicted when I was a kid, so I was bound to not let her get onto soda. Once, when she was little, she wanted some. I gave her diet soda. It set her pallate and she hated it (made sure it was extra fizzy, too).

I also made sure the first veggies and foods she had were the low carb/low sugar foods. Dramatically helped me over the years. She actually requests brussel sprouts. Go figger.