PDA

View Full Version : Overweight young women could die young


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



kebaldwin
Tue, Jul-18-06, 03:32
Overweight young women could die young

July 18, 2006 - 8:34AM

Young women who are overweight at the age of 18 have a higher risk of dying young, but medication and behavior therapy can help young people lose weight, US researchers reported on Monday.

A study of 102,400 female nurses showed that women who were overweight or obese when 18 drank more alcohol, smoked more and were less likely to exercise as teens - and were also more likely to die between the ages of 36 and 56.

The more a women weighed at 18, the greater her risk of dying young, the researchers reported in Monday's issue of the Annals of Internal Medicine.

Women who were moderately overweight at 18 were more than 50 per cent more likely to die in the 12 years of follow-up, and obese women were more than twice as likely to die, as the slimmest 18-year-olds.

"This paper underscores the importance of efforts to prevent excessive weight gain in children, not only to prevent obesity but also to prevent moderate overweight (people)," said Frank Hu of the Harvard School of Public Health, who worked on the study.

The women died of various causes - 258 died of cancer, 55 of heart disease or stroke and 61 committed suicide.

Even women who had never smoked were more likely to die if they remembered being overweight as 18-year-olds, the researchers found.

However, a second study found it is possible to help youngsters lose weight using behaviour therapy and the prescription drug sibutramine.

Dr Robert Berkowitz of Children's Hospital of Philadelphia and colleagues tested 498 obese youngsters aged 12 to 16.

Those given sibutramine, marketed by Abbott Laboratories as Meridia, lost more weight, the researchers reported in a second paper in Annals.

On average, the children who got the drug plus behavior therapy lost 8.2kg more compared to children who received behavioural therapy alone. On average, adolescents in the study who took a sugar pill gained 1.8 kg over the year.

The teens who got the drug also ended up with healthier levels of cholesterol and blood sugar, according to the study, paid for by Abbott. There was a side-effect, however - tachycardia, or rapid heartbeat.

"At the end of a year of treatment, one third of the adolescents who received medication were no longer severely overweight, and out of six who were treated dropped below the standard definition of being overweight," Berkowitz said in a statement.

In March, a US Food and Drug Administration staff report recommended against approving Meridia for use in children because there was so little information about its safety.

http://www.theage.com.au/news/World/Overweight-young-women-could-die-young/2006/07/18/1153166348458.html

SunnyCarol
Tue, Jul-18-06, 08:09
I love when they use the qualifying words "could" and "may" for these health articles. Anything "could" happen. The only time my daughter weighed over 100 pounds in her life was when she delivered her son in a full term pregnancy. She weighed 104 pounds and had a 7 pound 2 ounce baby. Nonetheless, she died "young" in 2004 at the age of 31. She died from the complications of diabetes and I've never seen anyone else eat as healthy as she did. The only bad thing that I ever saw her consume was too much coffee. I don't know of any of her overweight friends that have died.

I'm not saying that being overweight as a teen is not bad for them, just that these studies have little validity. Notice that they are pushing 'medication' yet again as the way to solve the problem. Our kids are way over-medicated as it is.

Sorry for the rant, but it's almost the anniversary of my beautiful daughter's death and she shouldn't be gone, if you believe all the stuff you read from research.

NewRuth
Tue, Jul-18-06, 08:31
Carol, I am sorry for your loss.

You're right about the "may"s, though. Here, let's give kids this drug so they live longer, nevermind the side effects!


The women died of various causes - 258 died of cancer, 55 of heart disease or stroke and 61 committed suicide.

Even women who had never smoked were more likely to die if they remembered being overweight as 18-year-olds, the researchers found.
So, their overweightness is measured by their "memories of being overweight"? When I was 18 I thought I was overweight. Now, I know that I was where my body was built to be. How much of this is peer pressure or depression generated?

kebaldwin
Tue, Jul-18-06, 15:58
Carol:

Sorry to hear about your daughter. Was it type 1 or type 2?

Congrats on your success.


Regarding the suicide comments in the article:

I don't think it has anything to do with remembering being overweight. One side effect of being overweight is anxiety / depression -- I would say that overweight people are more likely to commit suicide.

NewRuth
Tue, Jul-18-06, 16:32
One side effect of being overweight is anxiety / depression -- I would say that overweight people are more likely to commit suicide.
Or, is it one side effect of depression is overweight?

Snow_White
Tue, Jul-18-06, 20:34
Or, is it one side effect of depression is overweight?

Bingo! This was it in my case. A branch-off of my depression was binge eating, and developed into nightly binge eating disorder. This started when I was 15 or 16, I'm 20 now and 20-30 pounds overweight. :(