PDA

View Full Version : Why some just cannot resist food


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



Demi
Wed, May-17-06, 01:53
BBC News
London, UK
17 May, 2006


Scientists have discovered why some people just can't resist food.

They used scans to show the reward centres in some people's brains are particularly sensitive to food advertising and product packaging.

Greater stimulation of this area by food images is likely to encourage over-eating, and obesity.

The study, published in the Journal of Neuroscience, was carried out by the Medical Research Council's Cognition and Brain Sciences Unit.

The researchers showed people pictures of highly appetizing foods (eg chocolate cakes), bland foods (eg broccoli), and disgusting foods (eg rotten meat).

At the same time, they measured brain activity using a sophisticated fMRI scanner.

After testing, the study participants completed a questionnaire that assessed their general desire to pursue rewarding items or goals.

The results showed that the participant's scores on the reward sensitivity questionnaire predicted the extent to which the appetizing food images activated their brain's reward network.

False assumptions

Lead researcher Dr John Beaver said: "Previous studies in this area have assumed that brain activation patterns are similar in all healthy individuals.

"But the new findings demonstrate that, even in healthy individuals, some people's brain reward centres are more sensitive to appetizing food cues.

"This helps explain why some individuals are more vulnerable to developing certain disorders like binge-eating.

"This is particularly pertinent in understanding the rapidly increasing prevalence of obesity, as people are constantly bombarded with images of appetizing food items in order to promote food intake through television advertising, vending machines, or product packaging."

According to Dr Beaver the findings may also have broader implications for understanding vulnerability to multiple forms of addiction and compulsive behaviours.

He said: "Research demonstrates that an individual's reward sensitivity may also relate to their vulnerability to substance abuse, and the brain network we have identified is hyper-responsive to drug cues in addicts."

Industry responsibility

Dr Ian Campbell, an expert in obesity from Nottingham and medical director of the charity Weight Concern, said appetite control was notoriously difficult and most dieters regularly fail to control their food intake.

"This research this shows that it's not simply explained by a loss of will power or greed. It's much more complicated.

"An involuntary exaggerated neurophysiological response to pictures of desirable food presented through clever advertising makes it incredibly difficult for some affected individuals to resist.

"The message is clear. While individuals must retain a responsibility to do their best to control their intake of high fat high sugar foods this responsibility must be shared by the food manufacturers and advertisers.

"We need to move away from a position of simply blaming patients to one of greater understanding, and support."



http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4986262.stm

bkloots
Wed, May-17-06, 07:56
There's no doubt in my mind. Taking control of one's eating habits is a highly individual thing. Some people have to put more effort into it than others. It isn't "fair"--but nothing in the real world is.

I admit to eyeing obese people with a combination of judgment and compassion. As with any "religion," the pursuit of fitness gives you a vision of life at its best, and it's hard not to want to convert others to your own successful method. But as with religion, it's best not to talk about it unless invited. And then...only with caution.

ojoj
Wed, May-17-06, 09:00
I think eating too much is the human condition. In pre-history we were driven to hunt, gather and kill our food, probably at great risk to ourselves, so the need to eat had to be pretty strong. This need is still with us, but we dont have to use very much energy to satisfy this need anymore and there's far too much available anyway!

I'm also of the opinion that some people are addicted to sugar/carbs and just like some are addicted to cigarettes, alcohol, drugs, they just cant stop unless they give these things up completely - this is certainly the case for me, I've given up sugar but I still cant give up smoking though!!

cindie
Wed, May-17-06, 14:27
Yes you can quit!!! I said the same thing but I gave them up!!!

ItsTheWooo
Fri, May-19-06, 20:34
IMO, more an effect than a cause.

When you're hungry (or, desire more food than can be considered normal), obvoiusly you will find the image of a delicious piece of cake much more pleasurable than someone who's not as hungry. Personality differences aside (some people are just more "responsive" to pleasure than others due to neurophysiological differences between individuals), I can gaurentee those who produced the biggest responses (with pleausre) were those with "food issues": the obese, dieters, people with metabolic issues, so on.

This just basically confirms what everyone already knew: people who are obese desire food more than people who aren't obese. It doesn't even begin to explain WHY this difference exists.

Oh and this...

"This research this shows that it's not simply explained by a loss of will power or greed. It's much more complicated.

It is beyond scary that a scientist could say that. Willpower and greed are not real. Kind of of like love, willpower and greed are what we label (assign value) a particular mind/environment interaction result.

potatofree
Sat, May-20-06, 17:14
I think he may have been speaking of the values assigned to the overweight by society, meaning it's not the commonly-held notion of fat people being weak or greedy, but rather something much more complicated going on underneath... like the kinds of underlying physical problems you described or the heightened response they found.

kebaldwin
Sat, May-20-06, 17:40
I use to get a buzz from eating a large pizza or sub.

You should see what kids do when you tell them to stay away from high glycemic foods. They look like drug users trying to get their next fix.

I would call it an addiction.

ProfGumby
Sat, May-20-06, 18:08
I wonder how much of the association many people put on cakes, pies, and such has to do with the way we use/consume them in the context of family gatherings etc...

Consider this, we have cake and ice cream at birthday parties, lovely pies and sweet, decadent deserts at holiday gatherings...we do more of the same for graduations, anniversaries and on and on. We are all exposed to this at very young ages.

Is it slightly possible that most people associate these kinds of foods with many, many positive feelings? Or linking the eating of these foods to possibly thousands of good memories, the kind of memories that evoke emotional responses when we eat them?

Could this possibly influence the study?

kebaldwin
Sat, May-20-06, 19:26
Along those same lines ...

Many years ago I dated a lady from England that pointed out how Americans celebrate -- we typically go have a big, fancy meal.

bkloots
Sun, May-21-06, 05:07
Well, let's not think of the festive meal as an American quirk. Every culture in the world thoughout history does that.

kebaldwin
Sun, May-21-06, 06:10
Where were you when I was fighting with my girlfriend ?!?

Next time I get into a fight with a female -- I'll email you first :-)

(hold that thought honey -- I have to go e-mail ...)