PDA

View Full Version : Rhubarb's custard days are over


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



Demi
Thu, Mar-09-06, 02:37
The Times
London, UK
9 March, 2006

How slimming has put an old pudding filler back in fashion

HISTORICALLY found languishing soggily under a coating of lumpy custard, rhubarb has taken on a new lease of life, thanks to its discovery by health-conscious eaters.

Sales have doubled in the past year alone after the “forgotten vegetable” was championed by celebrity chefs and dieticians. Those red stems are low in carbohydrate but high in vitamin C, dietary fibre and potassium.

One of the chefs responsible for the rhubarb renaissance, Antony Worrall Thompson, has featured it heavily in his two books on the GI diet.

“I think the GI diet plays a part in the recent rise in demand for rhubarb,” he said. “Rhubarb is very healthy and it is excellent for the GI diet because it is low in carbohydrate.

“You can put it in a crumble and, as long as you don’t have too much sugar, it is very good for you. My favourite dish is a hot or cold rhubarb crumble or tart.”

Supermarkets experienced a 100 per cent increase in sales this January in comparison with 12 months ago — a faster increase than any other vege- table.

Janet Oldroyd-Hulme, of Oldroyd’s Farm in the so-called “rhubarb triangle” between Bradford, Leeds and Wakefield, supplies Asda and Sainsbury’s.

Over the past five years she has increased production from 500 tonnes a year to 1,000 tonnes, enough to make a rhubarb crumble the size of an Olympic swimming pool.

Mrs Oldroyd-Hulme, 53, said: “For people on GI diets, like other diets, rhubarb is a godsend and they have been clamouring for it.

“Dieters refer to it as a superfood because it helps to push toxins out of your system and speeds up your metabolic rate. Rhubarb is also high in calcium yet actually lowers your cholesterol, unlike dairy products.”

Until recently, rhubarb was confined to a forgotten corner of the allotment where its enormous, and poisonous, leaves hid the rosy red stems from view. But it was not always like that, according to Mrs Oldroyd-Hulme.

She said: “It used to be more popular than strawberries in this country, and the rate we are going it may well be like that again one day.

“In the Second World War, when there was rationing, people used to get a stick of rhubarb and a bag of sugar to satisfy their craving for something sweet. That gave rise to the modern day sherbert dip. But after the war sweets became more widely available and rhubarb got left behind.”

Claire Taylor, a spokeswoman for the supermarket chain Morrisons, said that one of the reasons rhubarb was more in demand was the GI diet. She added: “Rhubarb has always had a loyal following, but it seems that its popularity is on the up.”

The earliest records of rhubarb growing are from 2,700BC in China, where it was cultivated for medicinal purposes.

In Britain the plants spend two years in the open, absorbing sunshine and storing energy, before they are put in darkened sheds and warmed. In this way they grow longer and sweeter stalks, instead of producing leaves.

At the height of its popularity there were 200 growers in the rhubarb triangle and the area produced 90 per cent of the world’s winter rhubarb.

The GI — or glycaemic index — diet emerged about 1970 as a way for diabetics to control their insulin levels, but has since replaced the Atkins diet as the trendy way to lose weight. Among its enthusiasts are Kim Cattrall, one of the stars of Sex and the City, the model Jodie Kidd and the singer Kylie Minogue.



RISING TO A CHIC NEW ROLE

Rhubarb soup

Ingredients 1 stem rhubarb chopped, 2 tablespoons of red wine vinegar, 50g of caster sugar, 150g of water, Greek-style yoghurt or mascarpone cheese to serve

Method 1 Place the rhubarb in a bowl with two tablespoons of water and cook in the microwave for 3 to 4 minutes to soften

Method 2 Heat the red wine vinegar with the caster sugar and water in a pan. Bring to the boil and stir in the rhubarb. Serve with Greek yoghurt or a scoop of mascarpone

Source: Paul Rankin

Lamb and rhubarb ragout

Ingredients 500g of boneless stewing lamb, 125g of chopped onion, 15ml of cooking oil, 500g of carrots cut into julienne strips, 375g of rhubarb cut into 2cm pieces, 125ml of water, 50g of sugar, 25ml of lemon juice, chopped fresh parsley, pinch of cinnamon, nutmeg, salt and pepper

Procedure Brown the lamb with onion in oil. Add the remaining ingredients. Cover and bring to boil. Reduce and simmer for one hour, stirring often. Serve over noodles and sprinkle with chopped parsley, if desired.

Makes 4 servings.

Source: www.rhubarbinfo.com


http://www.timesonline.co.uk/newspaper/0,,173-2076414,00.html

neo_crone
Thu, Mar-09-06, 03:00
Personally, I love rhubarb and custard. Using splenda, its a perfect LC dessert!

bsheets
Thu, Mar-09-06, 04:37
I love rhubarb! Always have :yum:
Stopped eating it when I started lc though, does anyone have a good lc rhubarb recipe??

e

Demi
Thu, Mar-09-06, 05:01
Originally posted by bsheets
Stopped eating it when I started lc though, does anyone have a good lc rhubarb recipe??

Here you go, take a look through these (http://forum.lowcarber.org/search.php?searchid=914208) ~ can definitely recommend the Rhubarb Custard :)

Not sure why you stopped eating it though ~ it is very low in carbs :thup:



SORRY, the link no longer works - to find the recipes, just do an advanced search using the search link on the green bar above, put 'rhubarb' into the key words, ask to search 'titles only' and voila ~ you'll hopefully have a selection of recipes :)

Lessara
Thu, Mar-09-06, 10:26
What does it taste like? I never had it.

deb34
Thu, Mar-09-06, 11:17
Demi, you link didn't work for me, can you do it again?

thanks

arc
Thu, Mar-09-06, 12:33
What does it taste like? I never had it.

IMO, sour celery.

Rhubarb = :Puke:

MyJourney
Thu, Mar-09-06, 14:53
I would be curious about the taste as well. One of the veggies (I am assuming its a veggie?) I have never tasted.

zedgirl
Thu, Mar-09-06, 15:38
The Times
London, UK
9 March, 2006

One of the chefs responsible for the rhubarb renaissance, Antony Worrall Thompson, has featured it heavily in his two books on the GI diet.


How's the GI diet working for him? He looks quite obese on TV down here but I don't know how old his shows are.

MrMoose
Thu, Mar-09-06, 20:53
Well... with enough sugar anything is edible I suppose. :D But seriously Strawberry Rhubarb pie is good (sort of a sweet tart) but I imagine that huge quantities of sweetener would be required to make anything of it.

I really got a chuckle out of the article harping on the low GI and then giving recipes that are loaded with sugar. Yep, makes perfect sense. ;)

mike

kallyn
Thu, Mar-09-06, 22:54
Rhubarb has a ton of oxalic acid in it. I think oxalic acid suppresses thyroid, binds with certain nutrients and makes you deficient in them, and is even toxic in high doses. You should never eat raw rhubarb, or the leaves of rhubarb (raw or cooked) because of the oxalic acid content.

Here's a page on oxalic acid:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxalic_acid

In the "food science" section of the wiki it says:
Foods that contain significant concentrations of oxalic acid include (in decreasing order): buckwheat, star fruit (carambola), black pepper, parsley, poppy seed, rhubarb, spinach, chard, beets, banana, cocoa, chocolate, most nuts, most berries, and beans. In the case of rhubarb the only edible portion is the stalk because the root and leaves contain dangerously high concentrations of oxalic acid. The gritty feel one gets in the mouth when drinking milk with rhubarb desserts is caused by precipitation of calcium oxalate. Thus even dilute amounts of oxalic acid can readily "crack" the casein found in various dairy products.

Demi
Fri, Mar-10-06, 03:10
Just thought I'd share this interesting little rhubarb snippet:


The scientific chef

Peter Barham on rhubarb

Friday February 24, 2006
The Guardian


I'm told combining rhubarb and pineapple causes stomach upsets. True?


All parts of the rhubarb plant contain oxalic acid, a substance which, in combination with some nutrients (especially calcium salts), can be difficult to digest. However, the amount of oxalic acid present in rhubarb is small enough that it won't normally cause any problems. Pineapples contain a range of acids but hardly any oxalic acid; mixing rhubarb with pineapple will increase the overall amount of acid you are eating, but will barely increase the amount of oxalic acid at all. The only possible detrimental effect of adding pineapple to rhubarb could come from the strong enzymes in pineapple that break down proteins. If you hold fresh pineapple against your gums for a few minutes they tingle - the enzymes are eating into the proteins of your gums. There is a small amount of protein in the rhubarb's cell walls; if this is destroyed by the pineapple, it could make the cells weaker and easier to break, letting the oxalic acid out more easily. So you might taste more oxalic acid, but you wouldn't ingest any more. I don't think this is an issue.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/food/story/0,,1716821,00.html

Demi
Fri, Mar-10-06, 03:21
Originally posted by zedgirl
How's the GI diet working for him? He looks quite obese on TV down here but I don't know how old his shows are.
To be honest, I do wonder if he's just jumped on the bandwagon in order to sell recipe books - a case of 'do as I say, not do as I do'.

He's recently been hosting a live Saturday morning food show (http://www.bbc.co.uk/food/tv_and_radio/saturdaykitchen_index.shtml) here in the UK, and IMO doesn't look as though he's ever been on a 'diet', let alone the GI diet, in his life.

Demi
Fri, Mar-10-06, 05:04
More rhubarb snippets:

Rhubarb

Tart and tangy
Champagne rhubarb, one of the earliest crops of British rhubarb is much-loved for its fine flavour and slender pink stems. It’s pretty sour though and you’ll need a fair bit of sugar to sweeten it up.

By May, rhubarb becomes a darker colour, deepening to maroon by mid-summer – it also develops an even sharper flavour, although that can be easily sorted out by adding more sugar. These sturdy summer stems make great chutney, and are superb for making into fruit fools.

In the kitchen
Choose firm stems with fresh leaves. Before cooking, trim the base and leafy tops. Sturdier stems could need scraping with a vegetable knife to remove tough outer skin and fibres.

If you want rhubarb to keep its shape, the best way to cook it is by baking. Cut the stems into manageable lengths, and arrange in a roasting tin. Sprinkle with lots of sugar and add a dash of water. Cook, uncovered at 180C/gas 4 for about 20-30 minutes.

Rhubarb and custard is a classic British pairing, but ever popular family puddings include crumbles, steamed sponges and pies. In Europe, softened rhubarb is often filled into strudels and made into sweet, chilled soup.

Smooth rhubarb sauce goes down a treat with grilled oily fish such as mackerel and salmon.

Try serving poached rhubarb with clotted cream and a wedge of sticky gingerbread or buttery shortbread.

http://www.uktvfood.co.uk/index.cfm?uktv=ingredients.ingredientitem&iID=532957

Obviously, us low carbers will need to omit the sugar - however, I have found that Splenda does the job just as well.

Rhubarb and clotted cream is divine! :)

deb34
Fri, Mar-10-06, 06:34
i love rhubarb so much! i have fond memories of helping my grandmother pick it in her back yard and she would always give me a stalk and tiny cup of sugar to eat. Lick the stalk and dip in sugar and then bite.

I can smell her rhubarb preserves and pie right now.... that really takes me back to a great time when i was a kid.

LilithD
Fri, Mar-10-06, 17:39
What a load of nonsense. "Those red stems are low in carbohydrate but high in vitamin C, dietary fibre and potassium. "

By the time you've made it palatable it has a ton of carbs (sugar), unless you're using some other sweetener. And by the time you've made it soft enough to eat there would be very little Vit C left.

I do like rhubarb and apple crumble with cream or custard, but I'm not deluding myself that this is healthy food!

Shells90
Fri, Mar-10-06, 19:53
I love to eat it raw with some lite salt. It is the perfect answer for munching because you can not eat too much but the flavor is strong. I cut it in small strips after stripping the tough exterior. I have no added carbs but add pottassium with the salt. I just wish it was available more often in the stores because I very rarely get to indulge in this treat! My mouth is watering just thinking about it.

bsheets
Sat, Mar-11-06, 15:15
Not sure why you stopped eating it though ~ it is very low in carbs
It's the fact you need to sweeten it to eat it that made me stop eating rhubarb when I started lc. I thought if I couldn't have custard or pie crust with it, it would taste like 'sour celery' as someone else stated.

I've just looked up an old recipe book though, if you stew the rhubarb in water with stevia, place in a bowl then top with fondue (eggs, stevia, cream and cinnamon) it sounds like it would be delicious. I'll be making this as soon as I find a place that sells the stuff - I've never looked before, always bought preprepared!

Thanks though, adjusting existing recipes just never occurs to me :S

e

aj_cohn
Sun, Jul-27-08, 16:45
Kallyn,

I looked at the wikipedia reference, and it doesn't support your assertion that rhubarb or oxalic acid in general suppresses thyroid function. Do you have another citation for that?

Sandollar
Sun, Jul-27-08, 18:14
I buy it chopped up and frozen in the freezer aisle...I boil it down with a little water and sweetener until it's falling apart...then serve it hot with SF vanilla ice cream, creme fraiche or whipping cream.

Love the stuff!

Kansas Deb
Sun, Jul-27-08, 18:29
I buy it in the frozen fruit section. 1 cup in the microwave with a tablespoon of water coverd for 2 minutes. Stir and microwave an additional 1 minute if necessary. Add Splenda to taste or other AS, such as stevia or Eryithitol or a mixture. Then add a splash of heavy whipping cream. MMMM good! 1 cup cooks down to 1/2 cup.
Rhubarb doesn't taste like anything else I have ever eaten.

kallyn
Mon, Jul-28-08, 09:11
Kallyn,

I looked at the wikipedia reference, and it doesn't support your assertion that rhubarb or oxalic acid in general suppresses thyroid function. Do you have another citation for that?

Wow, old post! Looking back on it, I think I was confusing oxalic acid with goitrogens.