PDA

View Full Version : Eggs for Breakfast Aid Weight Control


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



nobimbo
Thu, Dec-29-05, 19:40
Eggs for Breakfast Aid Weight Control
Thursday December 29, 1:50 pm ET


WASHINGTON, Dec. 29 /PRNewswire/ -- Eating eggs for breakfast instead of a bagel can reduce hunger and caloric intake both at lunchtime and over the next 24 hours, according to a new study published in the latest issue of the Journal of the American College of Nutrition.

The study compared the effects on hunger of two calorically-identical breakfasts, one consisting of two scrambled eggs and two slices of toast with low-calorie jelly, and the other a 3 1/2-inch bagel with cream cheese plus a 3-ounce nonfat yogurt. The study was carried out in 28 overweight individuals, because previous research that found greater satiety from a high-protein breakfast had only tested normal weight individuals.

"Obesity is a serious problem in the United States and throughout the world," said Dr. Nikhil Dhurandhar of the Pennington Biomedical Research Center, the study's lead investigator. "Our hypothesis was that eggs could be useful in helping overweight people reduce their energy intakes, a prerequisite of losing weight. We needed to test it specifically in overweight and obese subjects instead of extrapolating the effects from their non-obese counterparts."

Subjects were randomly assigned to eat one of the two different breakfasts two weeks apart. Meals were prepared and eaten at the research facility to ensure complete control of the amounts consumed. Satiety and hunger after breakfast were evaluated by questionnaire and by measuring calories eaten at lunch, and from study subject diet diaries kept the following 24-hour period.

The researchers found that when participants had eaten the egg breakfast they consumed significantly less energy not only at lunch on that day, but also throughout the day and the next morning as compared to the bagel breakfast. On average they ate about 163 fewer calories for lunch, 263 fewer calories that day, and 418 fewer calories over a 24-hour period.

"Eggs are a convenient, affordable and nutritious food," said Dr. Dhurandhar. "They are an integral and established part of breakfast in many cultures and may be eaten safely on a regular basis. Recent data from the Nurses' Health Study showed that egg consumption did not contribute to the risk of coronary heart disease or stroke. Furthermore, eggs have a 50% higher satiety index than other common breakfast foods. These attributes suggest that eggs may be an important part of diets that promote weight management."

The findings from this study build upon earlier studies showing that protein-based breakfasts improved weight loss better than carbohydrate-focused breakfasts. One recent study from the University of Illinois, Urbana, found that a high protein breakfast increased loss of body fat and preserved lean muscle mass better than a high carbohydrate breakfast. The effects were increased when the dietary regime was combined with exercise.

In the current study, the researchers note that the sensation of satiety is multi-faceted, and eggs seem to have an impact on the psychological desire for food as well as the biochemical responses of the body to different types of nutrients. Dr. Dhurandhar and colleagues are currently carrying out longer-term studies to see the increased satiety and decreased energy intake translates into significant weight loss.

The study was a collaborative effort among researchers from Saint Louis University, Wayne State University (Detroit), the Rochester Center for Obesity Research and Treatment (Michigan) and the Pennington Biomedical Research Center (Baton Rouge). It was funded by the Egg Nutrition Center and the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

CONTACT: Kerri Reese


Aronow Communications 212-265-5100
For the American Egg Board/Egg Nutrition Center

http://biz.yahoo.com/prnews/051229/nyth042.html?.v=34

Samuel
Thu, Dec-29-05, 19:52
The study compared the effects on hunger of two calorically-identical breakfasts, one consisting of two scrambled eggs and two slices of toast with low-calorie jelly, and the other a 3 1/2-inch bagel with cream cheese plus a 3-ounce nonfat yogurt.
And if they have tried replacing the two slices of toast and jelly with meat or with two more eggs they could have made even greater discovery!

CindySue48
Thu, Dec-29-05, 20:51
True Samuel, but it's a start!!!!! Maybe next they'll realize the slight improvement in blood indicators was caused by this change too!

Dodger
Thu, Dec-29-05, 21:24
two calorically-identical breakfasts, one consisting of two scrambled eggs and two slices of toast with low-calorie jelly, and the other a 3 1/2-inch bagel with cream cheese plus a 3-ounce nonfat yogurt.A strange choice of food selections. Why toast (high carbs) with the eggs and why cream cheese (high fat) iwth the bagel and nonfat yogurt?

I'm not sure that the reason for less hunger can be attributed to any particular food item (although my guess would be the eggs).

ItsTheWooo
Fri, Dec-30-05, 00:48
A strange choice of food selections. Why toast (high carbs) with the eggs and why cream cheese (high fat) iwth the bagel and nonfat yogurt?

I'm not sure that the reason for less hunger can be attributed to any particular food item (although my guess would be the eggs).

Because they wanted to make the meals balanced I guess... they weren't really testing high carb or high fat or high protein but high eggs :).

I do think there is something about eggs in particular, apart from their being low carb. I was thinking about this the other day in fact (when I was in a down swing from the cranberry bread I ate). Whenever I have eggs for breakfast I eat way less all day.

nobimbo
Fri, Dec-30-05, 05:12
I do think there is something about eggs in particular, apart from their being low carb.

Some research last year pointed to the leucine in eggs as contributing to the weight loss benefit:

Eggs Help Lose Weight And Stabilize Glucose Levels
posted December 15, 2004

Leucine, an essential amino acid found eggs, provides a weight loss advantage during dieting by helping to reduce loss of lean tissue, promote loss of body fat, and stabilize blood glucose levels.

In the research, eggs are cited as an important dietary source of leucine as well as lutein and zeaxanthin and, in the case of the latter two, research shows lutein and zeaxanthin in eggs to be more bioavailable than from other food sources.

"We found that increasing high-quality protein in the diet, like that found in eggs, dairy products and meats, provides a metabolic advantage due to a high content of the branched chain amino acid (BCAA) leucine," says article author Donald K. Layman, Ph.D., Professor of Nutrition, Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition and Department of Internal Medicine, College of Medicine, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. According to Layman, both the amount of high quality protein consumed, as well as the time of day it is consumed, may play an important role in weight loss.

Layman found that unlike other essential amino acids, leucine plays several key roles in metabolism. "Leucine is key to the metabolic advantage of a higher protein diet because of its unique roles in regulation of muscle protein synthesis and insulin signaling," says Layman.

According to his research, eating more protein rich foods like eggs and limiting carbohydrates helps burn body fat and control hunger and cravings, leading to weight loss.

When limiting calories, Layman recommends daily intake of protein above 1.5 g/kg of body weight (or above 102 grams of protein daily for a 150-pound person); whereas the current Dietary Reference Intake (DRI) for protein is about half that, set at 0.8 g/kg of body weight (or 55 grams of protein daily for a 150-pound person).

Layman's research also suggests that increased use of high quality protein at breakfast, in particular, maybe important for the weight loss advantage of a higher protein diet. In a 10-week study, Layman showed that eating a high quality protein breakfast while losing weight helps maintain lean muscle mass, which is critical to long-term weight loss and maintenance.

The study, which investigated the efficacy of two 1,700-calorie weight loss diets among women aged 45 to 57 years, found that women who ate the higher protein breakfast foods including eggs, low fat dairy and lean meats (containing 10 grams leucine daily) lost slightly more weight, but of the weight lost, nearly twice as much was fat compared to those eating a carbohydrate rich breakfast (containing 5 grams leucine daily).

Source: Diabetes In Control.com: The December 2004 JACN Supplement contains proceedings from the First International Scientific Symposium on Eggs and Human Health: Transition from Restrictions to Recommendations, sponsored by the Egg Nutrition Center.

http://72.14.203.104/search?q=cache:X4M1YnXYe-IJ:www.defeatdiabetes.org/Articles/food041215.htm+eggs+for+weight+control+research&hl=en

littlejohn
Fri, Dec-30-05, 07:24
Even though the study was funded by Big Egg (Egg Nutrition Center), I have allways had good results when eating plenty of eggs. My thinking is that when I am eating eggs I am also cooking and therefore avoiding any processed food. But maybe there is something special about eggs. Or maybe it's the mayo in my egg salad!? Or maybe smelling boiled eggs is an appetite suppresant!?

Nancy LC
Fri, Dec-30-05, 08:27
Yeah, eggs have always been extremely satiating for me. Interesting about the Leucine! I've been taking that, and my elderly mother too, for the purpose of restoring lost muscle mass. Especially for her, she's really frail.

betnich
Fri, Dec-30-05, 11:00
Funny, I have had the same experience with eggs- or maybe it's the veggies and pat of butter I use when preparing them!

Kharma
Sat, Dec-31-05, 06:40
I have a random question. It does tie in so it's not totally OT or anything, but I also eat a lot of eggs a day and lately I've been wondering if there were issues about things like hormones or antibiotics in eggs from the chickens. I've read a few websites that were concerned about this but they were mostly vegan ones so I felt they had an agenda of sorts. How worrisome is this, or is it not at all?

littlejohn
Sat, Dec-31-05, 08:35
Kharma

Get the eggs from the free range chickens if you are worried. I pay from .08 per egg to .19. The .19 is for high quality eggs when I by at WalMart. Their cheap eggs are poor quality.

And you are correct to be a little suspicious of meat discussions on a Vegan board. Though I think processed meats (nitrates) are best avoided.

bladegem
Sat, Dec-31-05, 15:46
Eggs have the same effect with me, Woo. A couple of eggs for breakfast and I forget about eating until 3-4 PM.

Nancy LC
Sat, Dec-31-05, 16:45
Lets see, we had a poster for awhile that knew a lot about chickens. They're not fed hormones because they grow fast enough. Antibiotics I'm not sure. Maybe I can find his old posting that said.

ProfGumby
Sat, Dec-31-05, 16:52
When I read the headline, I thought all low carbers would think, "Well, DUH!" :lol:

I too have found that eggs have the hunger capping effect for me as well. It is not uncommon to have one or two eggs for breakfast, and a hard boiled egg or two throughout the day. I seem to have fewer hunger problems if a couple of eggs are in my day. I have to really agree with the egg commercial tag line from a few years back, "the incredible, edible egg!"

kebaldwin
Sun, Jan-01-06, 13:32
Most low carb doctors will tell you that eggs are nature's most perfect food because of the amino acids, sulfur and other nutrients in them. Ideally, you eat them raw for maximum nutrition.

Since eggs are so cheap -- even the organic / free range / high Omega 3 / healthy eggs are still cheap.

Samuel
Sun, Jan-01-06, 17:27
Many years ago, I was at the supermarket once when I saw a little book titled "Negative calorie foods, The more you eat these foods, the more you lose weight".

I read the book and found that eggs are on the top of their negative calorie food list. The rest have been mostly vegetable items. They claimed that the calories you spend to digest these foods exceed the calories you get from them.

I know that they have been exaggerating things a bit, but I do believe that eggs and lean meat are the most satiating foods you can eat.

stephiewil
Sun, Jan-01-06, 22:36
I used to put raw eggs in shakes when I was younger but then read it binds the absorbtion of biotin if you eat eggs raw. Has that veiw changed ? I like putting them in shakes for extra protien and thickening but have not done it because I have read that more than once.
I love to eat eggs in any way, boiled, fried,scrambed, omelets, poached, although without toast that is pointless,so I do not poach anymore, but eggs are a wonderful and inexpensive food.
Now, does anyone know the answer to this question. If you are sensitive to flax seed and unable to eat it for health reasons, if you eat the enhanced eggs where the hens are fed flax seed, will that affect the person who is sensitive to flax seed ?? If the benefits of eating the flax seeds are passed into the eggs, it seems to me some of the flax seed properties might be too. I have no idea how to find this out . Thought I would ask here, maybe someone will know !!!
Stephie

Dodger
Sun, Jan-01-06, 22:45
I used to put raw eggs in shakes when I was younger but then read it binds the absorbtion of biotin if you eat eggs raw. Has that veiw changed ? I like putting them in shakes for extra protien and thickening but have not done it because I have read that more than once.
I love to eat eggs in any way, boiled, fried,scrambed, omelets, poached, although without toast that is pointless,so I do not poach anymore, but eggs are a wonderful and inexpensive food.

The raw egg white does bind the biotin so that you do not absorb it. It you eat the raw yolks with the whites, the abundance of biotin in the yolk may overwhelm the the egg whites ability to block the biotin. I just eat my eggs cooked and don't have to worry about biotin.