PDA

View Full Version : Inquiry ordered into Atkins diet


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



Lez
Tue, Dec-20-05, 22:14
Inquiry ordered into Atkins diet


The Atkins diet's long-term effects are still unknown, experts warn
The controversial Atkins diet is to come under government scrutiny amid growing concern over obesity figures, it is reported.
The investigation will be carried out by the National Institute of Clinical Excellence (Nice).

About 10m Britons are believed to be following a diet at any one time, a third of them choosing Atkins-style, high-protein regimes.

Three-quarters of adults in the UK are reportedly overweight or obese.

The Atkins diet involves eating unrestricted amounts meat and other high protein food while restricting carbohydrates

The team that will evaluate it will be made up of up to 20 doctors, nutritionists and dieticians, the Independent on Sunday reports.

Unhealthy?

Critics of the Atkins diet claim it can have consequences such as kidney damage, thin bones and high cholesterol.

The potential long-term consequences of high-fat diets are still unknown, they warn, and are likely to include a higher risk of diabetes and early heart attack.

A recent study warned that the diet might also reduce woman's chances of conceiving.

But the diet, which leads to rapid weight loss, has been praised by scores of celebrities, including singer Robbie Williams and actress Jennifer Aniston, and has proved hugely popular with the public.

The Atkins company, which has launched a special food range to go with its diet books, has a turnover of about £60m.

Obesity 'epidemics'

Its biggest markets are the USA, Britain, Japan and Italy.

The investigation into the Atkins diet is part of the most comprehensive study of obesity in Britain so far.

It will be carried out by Nice, a regulatory body which provides national guidance on treatments and care in England and Wales, together with the Health Development Agency.

The inquiry comes in the wake of a damning report from the Commons Select Committee on Health, which criticised ministers for failing to tackle growing obesity rates.

The results of the study, which will be published in a year's time, is expected to have an impact on how doctors choose to treat their overweight patients.

LC_Dave
Tue, Dec-20-05, 23:56
Wow there are a lot of in-correct things stated about the Atkins diet in that report.


I'm hoping the outcome will be positive.

Like all these researches and studies, the nature of the outcome depends on the motives on the people organising the study.

Duparc
Wed, Dec-21-05, 06:59
Credit here has to go to the Common's Select Committee in making those in the position to do something to wake-up and do it!

Once more, another article peppered with contradiction like reporting in one year's time on the long-term effect of Atkins; long-term; in a year's time? I wonder if anyone on the appointed committee knows of anyone like myself who has been on the diet for 13 months? Doubtful. Is it likely that a new group will be formed of some who might not feel fully committed? Given that objectivity might just shine through the conservatism of the medical profession and the biases of those who continue to believe that saturated fat causes furred arteries and/or heart attacks then Atkins might finally win the day.

I would like to bet that Atkins will shine through and win the day, but, where I hedge my bet is in my lack of faith on the impartiality of my fellow beings whom I suspect may manoeuver to serve their own ends. Those self-fulfilling prophesies perpetuate and hence my uncertainty.

Not so many months ago a public study on the best diet was conducted by a tv programme here in the UK and Atkins came out the best, but, it was not without it critics nor those who found the discipline of dieting too demanding which diminished some of the credit due to Atkins.

Placing my pessimism aside, I will join its 'cheering' party!

bkloots
Wed, Dec-21-05, 09:33
Duparc, this overview article certainly does contain most of the usual wrong assumptions about the Atkins plan. "Unlimited" meats and "high fat" are not among its long-term recommendations.

I'm very suspicious of any study based on self-reporting. Hope they design this one with decent controls and oversight. They could probably find a fine pool of compliant subjects from UK participants on this website.

After three years on Atkins, now at maintenance, I feel that I'm still just beginning to refine the lifestyle choices that will enable me to continue on a healthy path. I actually look forward to this "diet" in my devotion to fitness for life.

deirdra
Wed, Dec-21-05, 09:56
I hope they can be impartial, but it sounds like they are expecting certain results before they even start: "The potential long-term consequences of high-fat diets are still unknown, they warn, and are likely to include a higher risk of diabetes and early heart attack."

I also hope that they only focus on people who have followed Atkins/PP for >12 months, as these people are probably very committed & not the usual fad-dieters who eat primarily frankenfoods, quit early, and give the Atkins WOL bad press.

kyrasdad
Wed, Dec-21-05, 10:27
I hope they can be impartial, but it sounds like they are expecting certain results before they even start: "The potential long-term consequences of high-fat diets are still unknown, they warn, and are likely to include a higher risk of diabetes and early heart attack."

The tone of the article suggests a predisposition against low carb, so we'll see. I do find it funny that they don't write about the long term effects of low fat dieting - like a near-universal failure rate at producing longterm weight loss. I don't mind (and in fact like) the fact that they intend to study Atkins over the long term, but would like emphasis also put on low fat or more restricted calorie diets as well.

I also hope that they only focus on people who have followed Atkins/PP for >12 months, as these people are probably very committed & not the usual fad-dieters who eat primarily frankenfoods, quit early, and give the Atkins WOL bad press.

You'd hope they would do that. It's difficult to say thaat a diet isn't effective long term unless you study its long term adherents and not the fadders who drift in and out of every diet type looking for magic.

betnich
Wed, Dec-21-05, 11:32
An investigation by an agency called "NICE" ?

Anybody here read C.S. Lewis' THAT HIDEOUS STRENGTH?

;-)

LadyBelle
Thu, Dec-22-05, 16:37
I have a feeling it will go the same as usual.

People on the diet will lose weight, get healthier and feel good. Yet the final report will read


"Ok for temperary results, yet this board recomends low fat with lots of whole grains for long term health and weight loss."

That is what they all do. They prove it's not that bad and may even be helpful, but heaven forbid they should actually make a recomendation that goes against the accepted dogma.

Galliard
Tue, Dec-27-05, 15:36
An investigation by an agency called "NICE" ?

Anybody here read C.S. Lewis' THAT HIDEOUS STRENGTH?

;-)

I read that part and I thought the whole thing was going to turn out to be a joke! (Of course, we know what happened when NICE tried to take over...)