PDA

View Full Version : Children who eat fries raise breast cancer risk


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



doreen T
Thu, Aug-18-05, 08:40
Children who eat fries raise breast cancer risk

Wed Aug 17, 11:47 PM ET

Reuters Health: Very young children who eat French fries frequently have a much higher risk of breast cancer as adults, U.S. researchers reported on Wednesday.

A study of American nurses found that one additional serving of fries per week at ages three to five increased breast cancer risk by 27 percent.

"Researchers are finding more evidence that diet early in life could play a role in the development of diseases in women later in life," said Dr. Karin Michels, of Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston and Harvard Medical School, who led the study.

"This study provides additional evidence that breast cancer may originate during the early phases of a woman's life and that eating habits during that phase may be particularly important to reduce future risk of breast cancer."

For their study, Michels and colleagues used an ongoing survey of female registered nurses. They studied 582 women with breast cancer and 1,569 women free of breast cancer in 1993.

Writing in the International Journal of Cancer, the researchers said they looked at the women's diets and at questionnaires filled out by the mothers of the participants.

One risk factor for breast cancer stood out: women whose mothers who said their daughters ate French fries had a higher risk of breast cancer. This increased 27 percent for each weekly serving reportedly eaten.

"These data have to be interpreted cautiously since the observed association between consumption of French fries and breast cancer is dependent on the validity of the maternal recall of the diet," said Michels.

"Mothers were asked to recall their daughter's preschool diet after the participants' breast cancer status was known and it is possible that mothers of women with breast cancer recalled their daughter's diet differently than mothers of healthy women," she added.

"Other foods perceived as less healthy such as hot dogs or ice cream however, were not associated with breast cancer risk."

A high-fat diet has been linked with breast cancer, which affects more than 200,000 U.S. women a year and is expected to kill 40,000 this year.


http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20050818/hl_nm/cancer_fries_dc


.

catfishghj
Thu, Aug-18-05, 15:48
It is not a high fat diet, it is a high trans fat diet.

kebaldwin
Thu, Aug-18-05, 16:21
Not only is the trans fat bad -- but high glycemic diet, which includes french fries, causes cancer also.

doreen T
Thu, Aug-18-05, 16:24
No mention of the sugary ketchup or soft drink consumed WITH the fries. Hmmm.

Aren't fried potatoes supposed to be full of acrylamide??


Doreen

bluesmoke
Thu, Aug-18-05, 17:10
The Swedish study on the production of cancer causing substances by cooking carbohydrates such as potatoes was reported here earlier. Nyah Levi

Dodger
Thu, Aug-18-05, 17:34
A medium McDonald's fries has about 50 grams of carbs.

kwikdriver
Thu, Aug-18-05, 17:56
Since this is talking about adulthood cancer caused by childhood behavior, I suspect the kids were eating fries before everything was being cooked in hydrogenated vegetable oils, so I doubt transfats were the culprit.

This is another worthless piece of research being churned out to scare people. It's epidemiological, and based on recollections that are what, 20 years old? 30? Older? It's a new low in journalistic/scientific silliness. I have no doubt french fries are bad for you, but this "research" is utterly meaningless from the standpoint of proving it. If research this ill-conceived and shoddy was being used to support low carbing, it would have been ripped to shreds, but because it supports conventional wisdom it's shoved into print.

kebaldwin
Thu, Aug-18-05, 19:10
But the low-fat, no meat, no eggs, no butter, high trans fat, high carb diet has been around for at least 20 years. I think they are talking about the results of 20 years on this diet.

grandpa
Fri, Aug-19-05, 08:19
Right on the money Kwikdriver! Also the headline grabbing announcement of "increasing risk by 25%" is nothing but an expression of relative risk increase. The absolute risk between the two groups is conveniently left out. We don't know if the risk increase is 1 in a billion to 1.25 in a billion, or 40 in a hundred to 50 in a hundred. (both are a 25% increase in relative risk). I'm not a defender of French fries, but even assuming the relationship is valid without the absolute risk the public is misled with these types of pronouncements.