PDA

View Full Version : Fruit juices blamed for rising obesity rate by the anti-carb crowd


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



Samuel
Sat, Aug-13-05, 16:57
http://www.health.com/health/article/0,23414,1076391,00.html

The Big Squeeze
by Stacey Colino

Fruit juices have been slammed for being high in carbs and low in fiber. But do they have any redeeming qualities? Get ready for a surprise.

Fruit juice has become the Britney Spears of the grocery store, typically scoffed at by those old enough to remember a time before ultra-low-rise jeans. Between being called liquid sugar by the anti-carb crowd and being blamed for the rising obesity rate among kids, it would seem that juices are simply not worth swallowing. (In fact, their sales dropped 1.4 percent between 2002 and 2003, the first decline in more than 6 years, according to a recent report by www.marketresearch.com (http://www.marketresearch.com/).) And mainstream nutritionists promote the whole fruit over juice for its fiber and pulp. But the truth is, some fruit juices do deserve a place at your table because of their nutrients and powerful disease-fighting properties.

In fact, there are times when juice is uniquely beneficial. After a workout, for example, it helps replace fluids and blood sugar and provides nutrients. Juice also comes in handy when eating is simply not convenient—when you’re driving, say, or traveling, but still want something with nutritional value.

Drink your vitamins
In the beverage hierarchy, real fruit juice trumps soda and fruit-flavored drinks on the nutrition front. And a glass of 100 percent juice counts as a serving of fruit. But not all juices are equally healthy. Apple juice, for example, is a relative lightweight as far as nutrients go; a cup of the average brand offers 103 milligrams of vitamin C (thanks to added ascorbic acid) and 295 milligrams of potassium, but little else.

On the other hand, purple grape juice is fast emerging as a health-protective powerhouse, mostly because it’s rich in polyphenols, a class of antioxidants that protects against certain forms of cancer and heart disease. In fact, a small study from Korea (partially funded by Welch Foods Inc.) found that drinking Concord grape juice daily for 8 weeks slightly reduced blood pressure in men with hypertension. Meanwhile, tomato juice, a concentrated source of lycopene (an antioxidant linked with reduced risks of prostate, breast, colorectal, and lung cancers), may bolster the immune system, reduce bad cholesterol, and make blood platelets less sticky.

To increase juices’ nutritional value—and, of course, their sales—some manufacturers are fortifying them with vitamins (such as antioxidants A, C, and E); minerals (like calcium); or certain phytochemicals (like plant sterols). Musselman’s, for instance, now offers apple juice infused with vitamin C and calcium. Wyman’s and R.W. Knudsen have introduced blueberry juices that boast natural antioxidants, while Minute Maid Premium Heart Wise contains plant sterols that help lower harmful LDL cholesterol. Other companies are blending vegetables into their fruit juices, making it easier for you to get your daily dose of veggies.

Those extras don’t permit a bottomless juice glass, though. The calories can add up quickly. An 8-ounce glass of OJ, for example, has 112 calories—roughly the same amount as two medium oranges—which is why experts recommend only 4 to 6 ounces a day.

Choose your juice
To squeeze the maximum benefits from each glass, buy only juices labeled “100% juice,” “pasteurized,” and “no added sweeteners” or “no sugar added.” And as with fruits and vegetables, it’s smart to aim for variety. “Rotate your choice of juices so that you get different color groups and different disease-fighting compounds,” advises David Heber, MD, PhD, professor of medicine and director of the Center for Human Nutrition at the University of California, Los Angeles. “Most Americans eat a diet that’s brown or beige. Juices can help bring more color into your diet.”

Dodger
Sat, Aug-13-05, 17:20
Anything can be make to sound healthy if you pick and choose what you report.

As an example

On the other hand, purple grape juice is fast emerging as a health-protective powerhouse, mostly because it’s rich in polyphenols, a class of antioxidants that protects against certain forms of cancer and heart disease. In fact, a small study from Korea (partially funded by Welch Foods Inc.) found that drinking Concord grape juice daily for 8 weeks slightly reduced blood pressure in men with hypertension.
I checked the Welch web site and here is what the study really said "the results were not considered significant".

Meanwhile, tomato juice, a concentrated source of lycopene (an antioxidant linked with reduced risks of prostate, breast, colorectal, and lung cancers), may bolster the immune system, reduce bad cholesterol, and make blood platelets less sticky.
Lycopene needs to be taken with fat to have any effect. Tomato juice has no fat.

To increase juices’ nutritional value—and, of course, their sales—some manufacturers are fortifying them with vitamins (such as antioxidants A, C, and E); minerals (like calcium); or certain phytochemicals (like plant sterols). Musselman’s, for instance, now offers apple juice infused with vitamin C and calcium. Wyman’s and R.W. Knudsen have introduced blueberry juices that boast natural antioxidants, while Minute Maid Premium Heart Wise contains plant sterols that help lower harmful LDL cholesterol. Other companies are blending vegetables into their fruit juices, making it easier for you to get your daily dose of veggies.Notice the the alleged health benefits are NOT due to the fruit juice, just to the additives.

CindySue48
Sat, Aug-13-05, 17:40
“Most Americans eat a diet that’s brown or beige. Juices can help bring more color into your diet.”
LOL Fresh veggies and fruit are even better!

ceberezin
Sat, Aug-13-05, 17:46
Once again, we see that nutritionists are only interested in what you put in your mouth. What happens to it after you swallow is outside their department.

We know that insulin prevents the absortion of nutrients, so all the sugar in those juices will render most of those nutrients useless. In particular, vitamin C is compromised by glucose since it is chemically similar to glucose and shares a receptor at the cellular level. Rosedale is very clear on all this.

kebaldwin
Sat, Aug-13-05, 17:54
I wonder what would happen if you took these healthy fruit juices, removed the sugar, and dehydrated them? I guess then you would have supplements?

The benefits of like 30 glasses of juice with 1% of the carbs?

CindySue48
Sun, Aug-14-05, 09:16
I wonder what would happen if you took these healthy fruit juices, removed the sugar, and dehydrated them? I guess then you would have supplements?

The benefits of like 30 glasses of juice with 1% of the carbs?
Now why would you want to remove the sugar?!?!?!?!

Don't you know that sugar has NOTHING to do with obesity? And you NEED sugar! EVERYONE knows we need sugar! :lol:

Actually they do this....somewhat. They take the fruit juice, remove the water.....then add it back again! Huh? :confused:

PaulaB
Sun, Aug-14-05, 11:15
Once again, we see that nutritionists are only interested in what you put in your mouth. What happens to it after you swallow is outside their department.

We know that insulin prevents the absortion of nutrients, so all the sugar in those juices will render most of those nutrients useless. In particular, vitamin C is compromised by glucose since it is chemically similar to glucose and shares a receptor at the cellular level. Rosedale is very clear on all this.

I think if a lot of people sent in the products after digestion they make get a bit interested!

ItsTheWooo
Sun, Aug-14-05, 12:44
Once again, we see that nutritionists are only interested in what you put in your mouth. What happens to it after you swallow is outside their department.

We know that insulin prevents the absortion of nutrients, so all the sugar in those juices will render most of those nutrients useless. In particular, vitamin C is compromised by glucose since it is chemically similar to glucose and shares a receptor at the cellular level. Rosedale is very clear on all this.

I think insulin resistance can prevent the body from effectively absorbing nutrients, but insulin itself is crucial for absorbing nutrition and retaining and using all manner of nutrient factors. Insulin resistance causes problems absorbing nutrition because insulin reistance is basically a disease where the body can't effectively respond to insulin anymore. It's not the insulin that's causing the problems but the resistance to it.

ceberezin
Sun, Aug-14-05, 13:33
I stand corrected. Insulin resistance causes the body not to absorb nutrients, not the insulin itself. But since most adults who have been eating the standard high carb diet all their lives have some degree of insulin resistance,and since insulin resistance is cumulative, it bugs me that nutritionists get away with giving advice like this which destroys people's health in the guise of improving it.