PDA

View Full Version : A burning issue - a UK doctor's view of low carbing


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



Demi
Sun, Jun-13-04, 03:49
Carbohydrates, not fatty foods, are the culprit for piling on the pounds, says Dr John Briffa

Sunday June 13, 2004
The Observer

The government has recently come under fire for its flabby attitude to the ballooning rates of obesity in the UK. However, even if politicians weigh into this area, my instinct is that reversing our growing epidemic will be akin to steering the Titanic away from the iceberg. The situation that we have taken a few decades to get into could quite easily take a few decades to get out of. I suspect many of us will be wanting results more rapidly.
Statistics show that, at any given moment, one in four of us is on a diet. This figure bulges at this time of year as we are faced with the prospect of revealing our bums and tums on the beach. For most, the investment made in terms of dietary restraint will be repaid in the form of lost pounds. Chances are, though, that a year from now most would-be slimmers will find themselves no lighter, and may even have gained a few pounds. The problem is not just losing weight, but keeping it off.

Although the reasons for weight regain are complex, the primary cause is almost certainly reverting to our default diet. Dietary predilections are notoriously intransigent, so I was interested to read a recent report suggesting that many individuals who have come off a carbohydrate-restricted diet, such as Atkins, continue to avoid fattening foodstuffs such as soft drinks and confectionery.

This offers a glimmer of hope for those seeking to shed pounds permanently, as there is good reason to believe that long-term restriction of specific carbohydrates can help maintain weight loss. Eating fewer carbs ensures that the body makes less insulin - a hormone that predisposes the body to lay down fat and at the same time stalls the body's fat-burning potential.

Several studies show that restricting the intake of carbs is generally more effective for weight loss than low-fat diets. Considerable evidence now exists showing that low-carb eating brings about favourable changes in blood fats, including higher levels of 'healthy' high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol and lower levels of unhealthy triglycerides.

Only last month, a study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine found that individuals on a low-carb diet were better able to stick to it than those following a low-fat regime.

This mirrors my own experience as a practitioner that many individuals find eating less refined sugar (as found in soft drinks and confectionary) and grain-based starches (such as bread, breakfast cereals, pasta and rice), quite sustainable, and can look forward to long-term weight loss as a result. Basing the diet around natural, unprocessed foods (such as meat, fish, eggs, fruit, green vegetables, nuts, beans and lentils) which tend not to disrupt the body's biochemistry really does seem to ensure that weight shed this summer is kept off permanently.


http://observer.guardian.co.uk/magazine/story/0,11913,1235853,00.html

ellemenno
Sun, Jun-13-04, 06:54
Maybe the medical profession is actually beginning to see the light. It appears as though more and more doctors are slowly changing their opinion of the low carb diet.

One of my friends recently discovered her brother is glucose intolerant. She had no idea what that was and came to me when she found out he was told to go on a low carb diet. I was so excited to hear the doctor suggest low carb that I forgot to explain the whole glucose intolerance part to her!

DebPenny
Sun, Jun-13-04, 07:59
Yes, the doctors actually do seem to be coming around. Now if we could just get the nutritionists and dieticians to see light, we'd really be on the road to low-carb enlightenment. ;)

PacNW
Sun, Jun-13-04, 17:29
This is one isolated doctor writing an op-ed piece. I wouldn't leap from that to "the doctors actually do seem to be coming around."

tofi
Sun, Jun-13-04, 18:14
But he's not the only one. And more will read this article. My own GP, who has always said I should do WW, was amazed that almost 5 years of LCing had given me a FABULOUS cholesterol ratio and triglycerides in the "well below average" risk category.

EvelynS
Mon, Jun-14-04, 04:17
This is one isolated doctor writing an op-ed piece. I wouldn't leap from that to "the doctors actually do seem to be coming around."

I don't think the doctors in the UK have ever been the problem, for the most part they are a sensible lot. It's the dieticians who have been most threatened by the low-carb trend and are taking longer to shift their position. It's an embarrassing situation for them, having been so gung-ho about low fat eating. Perhaps the litigation situation in the US affects doctors more than here.

Katy131
Mon, Jun-14-04, 09:32
oooh I love that Dr John Briffa - if I wasn't already married, I'd be picking out curtains!! :lol: Here's his website:

http://www.drbriffa.com/index.asp

I've come across him before a few times - he was on a British documentary about low carb diets about a year ago, and was about the only medic talking sense. He's also written several great articles for the Observer over the past couple of years (just put his name into Google).

It's very good for a poor struggling low carber to find a doctor from the younger generation who is helping us out there in the real world media. I think we should elect him our honorary low carb guru :D

Nancy LC
Mon, Jun-14-04, 11:22
The good news is that doctors who actually did think low-carb was ok wouldn't have spoken out about it before for fear of being ostracized by their profession. So I think nowadays its a little more acceptable for them to acknowledge that its an ok diet.