Could you pleaseshare your experiences of switching from Atkins to the SBD? : South Beach Diet : Active Low-Carber Forums

View Full Version : Could you pleaseshare your experiences of switching from Atkins to the SBD?

Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!

toning_up

Mon, Mar-15-04, 05:24

Hi everyone,

I am considering switching over from Atkins to SBD. I have been doing Atkins for 10 weeks now and apart from a 4 lbs loss during induction and 2 or 3 lbs I've been yo yo-ing with after that, I really haven't seen the results I was hoping for.

During those 10 weeks I have been following induction very strictly. My only planned cheat during that period was a recent few glasses of red wine at dinner once. Other than that, a clean by the book induction.

What can I expect switching to phase 1 of SBD? I'm not expecting the initial whoosh of water weight because that has already happened with Atkins. But is there anything else you can share about your experience and general feeling about the SBD?

I need to read the book starting today before I start. I can never start anything without reading eveything I can on a subject, but I thought I'd try to begin modifiying my induction as of today. Lowering the fat and so on. Any tips there to get me started?

Thanks....I appreciate it.

Kimmerz321

Mon, Mar-15-04, 10:40

There's a thread just below you that talks about a lot of the stuff you're asking about - it's at
http://forum.lowcarber.org/showthread.php?t=171669

Hopefully that'll answer some of your questions. :)

wow

Mon, Mar-15-04, 14:59

Definitely search the threads. I found several on this topic which encouraged me to switch to the SBD. I am on day 1 of phase II. I did atkins induction and made the switch. So far so good but I have eaten wayyy to many nuts which are allowed on the sbd.

There is also a thread called phase I which list exactly what you can eat. Goood Luck!

toning_up

Mon, Mar-15-04, 15:54

Thanks guys. I bought the book this morning and I'm about a 1/4 way through right now. What he writes really makes sense. I also like that he's very gracious to Atkins, Pritikin et al while still respectfully disagreeing with some of their philosophies.

Wow, what I specifically wanted to know from "switchers" is this: Did you switch and just keep gradually losing or was their a little hiatus where you lost nothing and even gained or did you get the whoosh that new LCers get when they begin dieting for the for first time?

I guess I'm wondering what I may be expecting reasonably over the next 2 weeks.

babydoll23

Tue, Mar-16-04, 13:15

I too was thinking of switching to atkins. I just am not "into" atkins anymore. I miss things like the occasional yogurt and I really don't like lots of fatty meats and grease. I also like how phase II does include the fruits. I have been off and on of atkins for something like a year and a half now and have heard good things about the SBD. i am looking into making hte switch so i was glad to see this post!