PDA

View Full Version : Low Carb Diet Linked to Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma


Welcome to the Active Low-Carber Forums

Support for Atkins diet, Protein Power, Neanderthin (Paleo Diet), CAD/CALP, Dr. Bernstein Diabetes Solution and any other healthy low-carb diet or plan, all are welcome in our lowcarb community. Forget starvation and fad diets -- join the healthy eating crowd! You may register by clicking here, it's free!



nobimbo
Wed, Mar-10-04, 04:18
Diet Linked to Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma

Lots of Meat, Saturated Fat, Dairy May Raise Risk

By Daniel DeNoon
WebMD Medical News Reviewed By Brunilda Nazario, MD
on Tuesday, March 09, 2004

March 9, 2004 -- What's causing America's huge surge in blood cancer? It might be our diet.


It's called non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. It's a killer collection of different white-blood-cell cancers. And it's a mystery why it's been increasing so quickly in the U.S. and other parts of the world.


Now there's a clue. It comes from a study of 601 Connecticut women with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. Tongzhang Zheng, ScD, head of the division of environmental health sciences at the Yale School of Public Health in New Haven, Conn., collected detailed dietary information from these women and from 717 similar women without cancer.


"What we found is if a person has a higher intake of animal protein, they will have a higher risk of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma," Zheng tells Web. "And people who have a higher intake of saturated fat have an increased risk. On the other hand, if you have higher-than-average intake of dietary fiber -- particularly if you frequently eat vegetables and fruits with a high fiber content -- you have a reduced risk of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma."


The findings appear in the March 1 issue of the American Journal of Epidemiology.


Earlier studies hinted at the same thing. Now, Zheng says, it seems clear that a major factor in the mysterious rise of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma is a diet high in meat, saturated fats, dairy products, and eggs and low in fiber, fruits, and vegetables.


Unbalanced Diet, Unhealthy Body


In the U.S., three kinds of cancer have skyrocketed in recent decades. One is lung cancer, mainly caused by smoking. Another is skin cancer, caused by too much sun. The third is non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. But nobody knows why it's on the rise, says Nancy Mueller [pronounced MULL-er], ScD, associate director of population sciences at Harvard's Dana-Farber Cancer Center.


"Non-Hodgkin's lymphoma is a basket of related diseases," Mueller tells WebMD. "It probably has a set of causal factors that may be related to one another, but not in a simple way. We can't really explain it -- this is a really hard nut to crack. But what is happening to the American is associated with a number of malignancies such as breast, kidney, and colon cancer. Higher body weight is a common theme."


A high-fat diet may indeed be linked to higher body weight. But Zheng says that people eating low-carb diets may also be at risk of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma if they eat too much meat and too few vegetables.

One thing that's known about non-Hodgkin's lymphoma is that people whose immune systems aren't working well -- such as AIDS patients -- are at increased risk. Zheng suggests that immune function depends on proper nutrition.


"Your body is designed to repair things," Zheng says. "But if your body is not getting proper nutrition, how can the immune system continue to function? Everything relates to the nutrients in your dietary intake."


Cancer-Fighting Foods


Zheng says that it's not necessary to stop eating meat. Nor it is necessary to gobble up huge quantities of vegetables. A balanced diet, he says, is all that's needed.


His study showed that people who ate more of certain foods tended to have a lower risk of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. Those foods include:


Tomatoes
Broccoli
Squash
Cauliflower
Onions
Mixed lettuce salad
Leeks
Apples
Pears
Citrus fruits

Improving your diet won't just lower your cancer risk, Mueller notes.


"There is such a confluence between risk factors for cancer and risk factors for heart disease," she says. "Get plenty of exercise, eat a good diet, don't smoke. It is what your mother told you. It's true that this is the basis of a healthy lifestyle. And it's true that this lowers your risk for these big killers, too."

http://my.webmd.com/content/article/83/97796.htm?z=1728_00000_1000_ln_02

Angeline
Wed, Mar-10-04, 05:49
Gimme a break. Are these people irresponsible or what. He's supposed to be an MD, not a writer for the Inquirer. In other words he's supposed to write articles based on science and thruth, not about UFO and 2 headed midgets ballerinas. The real "fad" these days is to blame everything wrong in American on Atkins. I am waiting for the day they will blame disintegrating moral values, the War in Iraq and My Big Fat Fiance on Atkins. Linking it to a low-carb diet is cheap to say the least. They are implying that Low-Carb could have contributed to the rise of this disease, when it's quite impossible since none of the people studied was doing low-carb. Has it occured to them that the people who were consuming less fruits and vegetables were maybe the ones who eat a lot of highly processed carbs ? Has that even been looked at in this study ? Of course not, since everyone knows that carbs are completly harmless right ? Wouldn't it be more logical to assume that the American diet of highly processed carb and very little fruit and vegetables that has been the mainstay for the past 20 years could be more at blame than the recent lowcarb "fad"? Well no, that's way too boring, let's blame low-carb again...so much more "in". Let's blame the new guy for everything wrong with this town, this way we don't have to look too closely at our long-time neighbours. Typical human attitude.

All he had to do is tell people once again that eating fruits and vegetable is important for health. He could have added that if you are low-carbing not to neglect your veggies. He could have pointed to the study. Attempting to put the blame on low-carbing is just cheap. Just cheap.

Grrrr.... sorry for the rant.

Kestrel
Wed, Mar-10-04, 06:02
The sky is falling, the sky is falling...

Oh, wait, nowadays that probably should be: the ozone layer is falling, the ozone layer is falling...

gotbeer
Wed, Mar-10-04, 06:36
Actually, I blame the loss of the ozone layer on Low-carb diets.

It works like this: low-carb foods need to be refrigerated. More refrigeration means more production of the gases used in refrigerators. Those gases leak out, and destroy the ozone.

I'm sort of surprised the PCRM hasn't used this one yet.

cc48510
Wed, Mar-10-04, 08:53
Here's the kicker on this one, read the lines for Animal Fat and Vegetables on this USDA Chart. If the rates are soaring, it is NOT because we're eating more Animal Fat and Animal Protein, or because we're eating less "Vegetables":

http://www.cs.uwf.edu/~ccarr/food.jpg
http://www.cs.uwf.edu/~ccarr/fatgram.png
http://www.cs.uwf.edu/~ccarr/fatcal.PNG
http://www.cs.uwf.edu/~ccarr/mencal.png

K Walt
Wed, Mar-10-04, 10:16
Thanks cc. . .

Looks like another example of 'scientists' spinning the data to fit pre-conceived notions, then the press further spinning the spin to give it all a great 'hook', but, as usual, meaning absolutely zilch.

K Walt
Wed, Mar-10-04, 10:22
Next, we're gonna see headlines. . .

"Studies show that having FRIENDS on low-carb diets can harm YOUR health."

According to a physician's group, if your friends and co-workers are "chowing down", "gorging", 'filling up", and otherwise "scarfing" "high-fat fare" as recommended by the Atkins Diet, it can actually affect your kidneys, raise your risk of heart attack, gout, depression, stroke, bad breath, and muscle wasting.

"It's frightening," says Veg O'Matic, MD, "but we have actually seen clogging arteries in people whose next door neighbors are on the all-bacon Atkins Diet. It's sort of like second-hand fat, and it's deadly."


Don't laugh, it's coming.

CindySue48
Wed, Mar-10-04, 17:44
LOL K Walt! That is a riot!

daninmidmo
Wed, Mar-10-04, 18:09
I think it far more likely that the increase in use of HFCS, sugar, starch, and highly processed foods with lots of unnatural additives is the culprit in most modern diseases. That and the diet our meat animals eat in factory farms.

Basically, I think Weston Price [ http://www.westonaprice.org ] had a good handle on things, they have just continued spiralling out of control since his time. More people are revolting against the food situation every day, in spite of all the propaganda, since they have seen how horribly unsuccessful following the government and food industries diet recommendations (or ignoring what the companies put in the food supply) is in the long and even short run.

TBoneMitch
Wed, Mar-10-04, 19:07
Isn't WebMD run by our old friend Dean Ornish? Just a thought...

Kristine
Wed, Mar-10-04, 19:26
Not that I know of. He's just a contributor.

CindySue48
Wed, Mar-10-04, 19:32
Isn't WebMD run by our old friend Dean Ornish? Just a thought...

I don't know who run WebMD, but they promote low fat, cholesterol, lipids. I've yet to see anything pro-LC on there! Oh yea....they also don't recomend eggs. Well, I should say egg yolks. You can have the whites. No fat, you see!